Determination of the level of sustainable development of the cities - a proposal for a method of classifying objects based on natural breaks

Krzysztof Rząsa; Mateusz Ciski

doi:10.31648/aspal.6701

Published: 2021-10-041

Vol. 20 No. 3 (2021)

Determination of the level of sustainable development of the cities - a proposal for a method of classifying objects based on natural breaks

Krzysztof Rząsa

, Mateusz Ciski

Acta Scientiarum Polonorum Administratio Locorum

Section: Articles

https://doi.org/10.31648/aspal.6701

Abstract

Motives: The problem of measuring the level of sustainable development is a subject addressed by many authors in their research.

Aim: In this article the Authors proposed a new method of classifying objects based on Jenks’ Natural Breaks to measure the level of sustainable development. The analysis was carried out on the basis of the data obtained from Statistics Poland. An important element of the research was the development of the process of selection and rejection of input data on the basis of a variety of statistical indicators. This resulted in a set of data which, on the one hand, is statistically justified and, on the other, describes the examined phenomenon in a comprehensive way.

Results: The research objects were 66 Polish district cities; Authors obtained a ranking of cities in terms of its Sustainable Development Level. The authors decided to verify the correlation of the results obtained from a proposed method of classifying objects based on natural breaks, with those from the chosen taxonomic method (Hellwig’s method) and the Classic Ranking. The fact of receiving highly correlated results confirms the validity and reliability of the proposed method.

Keywords:

sustainable development, Jenks’ Natural Breaks, Hellwig’s method, Classic Ranking method

Most read articles by the same author(s)

Krzysztof Rząsa, Ph.D., Giacomo Caporusso, Marek Patrycjusz Ogryzek, Ph.D., Eufemia Tarantino, Spatial planning systems in Poland and Italy - comparative analysis on the example of Olsztyn and Bari , Acta Scientiarum Polonorum Administratio Locorum: Vol. 20 No. 2 (2021)

Download files

PDF

Citation rules

Rząsa, K., & Ciski, M. (2021). Determination of the level of sustainable development of the cities - a proposal for a method of classifying objects based on natural breaks. Acta Scientiarum Polonorum Administratio Locorum, 20(3), 215–239. https://doi.org/10.31648/aspal.6701

Cited by / Share

Licence

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

References

Act of 27 April 2001 Environmental Protection Law, 62 Polish Journal of Law § (2001) (Poland).
Google Scholar

Adamowicz, M., Janulewicz, P. (2016). Ocena poziomu rozwoju dużych miast w Polsce – Wyniki badań wykorzystujących wzorzec rozwoju Hellwiga [Evaluation of the level of development of large cities in Poland – results of studies using the Hellwig’s development model]. Studia Regionalne i Lokalne [Regional and Local Studies], 64(2), pp. 68–86. doi:10.7366/1509499526404.
Google Scholar

Aggarwal, C.C. (2014). Data classification: Algorithms and Applications. London, Chapman and Hall/CRC.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Alkhalidi, A., Qoaider, L., Khashman, A., Al-Alami, A.R., Jiryes, S. (2018). Energy and Water as Indicators for Sustainable City Site Selection and Design in Jordan using smart grid. Sustainable Cities and Society, 37, pp. 125–132. doi:10.1016/j.scs.2017.10.037.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Aly, M. (2005). Survey on multiclass classification methods. Neural Networks, Caltech.
Google Scholar

Antonopoulos, E. (2018). Sustainable Urban Development in Greece Using Integrated Territorial Investments. European Structural & Investment Funds Journal, 6(1), pp. 28–34.
Google Scholar

Atkinson, G., Dubourg, R., Hamilton, K., Munasinghe, M., Pearce, D., Young, C. (1997). Measuring Sustainable Development: Macroeconomics and the Environment. Cheltenham, Edward Elgar Publishing.
Google Scholar

Azapagic, A., Perdan, S. (2000). Indicators of sustainable development for industry: A general framework. Process Safety and Environmental Protection, 78(4). doi:10.1205/095758200530763.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Bąk, A. (2016). Porządkowanie liniowe obiektów metodą Hellwiga i TOPSIS – analiza porównawcza [Linear ordering of objects using Hellwig and TOPSIS methods – a comparative analysis]. Taksonomia 26 Klasyfikacja i analiza danych – teoria i zastosowania [Taxonomy 26 Classification and Data Analysis – Theory and Applications], pp. 22–31. doi:10.15611/pn.2016.426.02.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Bąk, I., Cheba, K. (2018). Syntetyczna ocena dysproporcji zrównoważonego rozwoju krajów Unii Europejskiej [Synthetic evaluation of disproportions of sustainable development of the European Union countries]. Wiadomości Statystyczne [Statistical News], 5(684), pp. 37–55.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Bell, S., Morse, S. (2018). Routledge Handbook of Sustainability Indicators. Londyn, Routledge.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Bossel, H. (1999). Indicators for sustainable development: theory, method, applications. International Institute for Sustainable Development, Winnipeg.
Google Scholar

Chen, J., Yang, S., Li, H., Zhang, B., Lv, J. (2013). Research on geographical environment unit division based on the method of natural breaks (Jenks). International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences – ISPRS Archives, 40(4W3), pp. 47–50. doi:10.5194/isprsarchives-XL-4-W3-47-2013.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Ciski, M., Rząsa, K. (2018). Cultural Parks in the Spatial Planning System in Poland. Proceedings – 2018 Baltic Geodetic Congress, BGC-Geomatics 2018, pp. 145–149. doi:10.1109/BGC-Geomatics.2018.00033.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Ciski, M., Rząsa, K., Ogryzek, M. (2019). Use of GIS tools in sustainable heritage management-the importance of data generalization in spatial modeling. Sustainability, 11(20). doi:10.3390/su11205616.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Czermińska, M. (2002). Zastosowanie metod taksonomicznych w klasyfikacji krajów Unii Europejskiej z punktu widzenia poziomu ich rozwoju gospodarczego [Application of taxonomic methods in the classification of European Union countries from the point of view of their level of economic development]. Zeszyty Naukowe Akademii Ekonomicznej w Krakowie [Scientific Journals of the Cracow University of Economics], 575(284), pp. 149–161.
Google Scholar

Dasgupta, P. (2007). Measuring sustainable development: Theory and application. Asian Development Review, 24(1), pp. 1–10.
Google Scholar

Dorożyński, T., Dobrowolska, B., Kuna-Marszałek, A. (2019). Institutional Quality As A Determinant of FDI Inflow: The case of Central and Eastern European Countries. Journal of Management and Financial Sciences, XII(36), pp. 103–122.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Drabarczyk, K. (2017). Zrównoważony rozwój województw – analiza porównawcza [Sustainable Development of Regions – A Comparative Analysis]. Zeszyty Naukowe Politechniki Częstochowskiej Zarządzanie, 25(2), pp. 23–34. doi:10.17512/znpcz.2017.1.2.02.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Drastichova, M. (2017). Measuring Sustainability of the EU Countries with the Selected Indices. The International Scientific Conference INPROFORUM 2017, 11–20. Česke Budějovice.
Google Scholar

European Commission. (2015). Indicators for sustainable cities. Science for Environment Policy. doi:10.2779/61700.
Google Scholar

European Commission. (2016). Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, he European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions. Strasbourg.
Google Scholar

EUROSTAT. (2019). Indicators – Eurostat. https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/sdi/indicators, date: 15.07.2020.
Google Scholar

Fierich, J. (1957). Próba zastosowania metod taksonomicznych do rejonizacji systemów rolniczych w województwie krakowskim [An attempt to use taxonomic methods for regionalization of agricultural systems in the Krakowskie Voivodeship]. Myśl Gospodarcza [Economic Thought], 1.
Google Scholar

Gorzelak, G. (1979). Dobór zmiennych w statystycznej analizie porównawczej – metody (I) [Selection of variables in comparative statistical analysis – methods (I)]. Wiadomości Statystyczne [Statistical News], 3, pp. 17–21.
Google Scholar

Gorzelak, G. (1981). Statystyczna analiza porównawcza – teoria a praktyka [Statistical comparative analysis – theory versus practice]. Wiadomości Statystyczne [Statistical News], 8.
Google Scholar

Grabiński, T., Wydymus, S., Zeliaś, A. (1989). Metody taksonomii numerycznej w modelowaniu zjawisk społeczno-gospodarczych [Methods of numerical taxonomy in modeling of socio-economic phenomena]. Warszawa, PWN.
Google Scholar

Hak, T., Janouškova, S., Moldan, B. (2016). Sustainable Development Goals: A need for relevant indicators. Ecological Indicators, 60. doi:10.1016/j.ecolind.2015.08.003.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Hellwig, Z. (1968). Zastosowanie metody taksonomicznej do typologicznego podziału krajów ze względu na poziom rozwoju i strukturę kwalifikowanych kadr [Application of the taxonomic method to the typological division of countries by the level of development and the structure of qualified human resources]. Przegląd Statystyczny [Statistical Review], 4, pp. 307–327.
Google Scholar

Hellwig, Z. (1981). Wielowymiarowa analiza porównawcza i jej zastosowanie w badaniach wielocechowych obiektow gospodarczych [Multivariate comparative analysis and its application in the study of multivariate economic objects]. In: Metody i modele ekonomiczno-matematyczne w doskonaleniu zarządzania gospodarką socjalistyczną [Economic and mathematical methods and models in improving the management of the socialist economy]. W., Welfe (ed.). Warszawa, PWE.
Google Scholar

Ilnicki, D. (2002). Proba określenia zmienności czasowej zjawisk przestrzennych metodami wzorcowymi – przykład metody Hellwiga [An attempt to determine the time variability of spatial phenomena by model methods – an example of Hellwig’s method].
Google Scholar

In: Możliwości i ograniczenia zastosowań metod badawczych w geografii społeczno-ekonomicznej i gospodarce przestrzennej [Possibilities and limitations of research methods application in social and economic geography and spatial economy]. H., Rogacki (ed.). Poznań, Bogucki Wydawnictwo Naukowe.
Google Scholar

Jaworska, M., Luty, L. (2009). Ocena rozwoju społeczno-gospodarczego powiatów województwa małopolskiego [Evaluation of socio-economic development of poviats of Lesser Poland Voivodeship]. Acta Scientiarum Polonorum Oeconomia, 8(3), pp. 37–44.
Google Scholar

Jenks, G.F. (1967). The data model concept in statistical mapping. International Yearbook of Cartography, 7, pp. 186–190.
Google Scholar

Khamis, N., Sin, T.C., Hock, G.C. (2018). Segmentation of Residential Customer Load Profile in Peninsular Malaysia using Jenks Natural Breaks. 2018 IEEE 7th International Conference on Power and Energy, PECon 2018, pp. 128–131. doi:10.1109/PECON.2018.8684113.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Klopp, J.M., Petretta, D.L. (2017). The urban sustainable development goal: Indicators, complexity and the politics of measuring cities. Cities, 63, pp. 92–97. doi:10.1016/j.cities.2016.12.019.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Kloska, R. (2017). Rozwój zrównoważony regionów w Polsce w ujęciu statystycznym [Sustainable development of regions in Poland in statistical perspective]. Progress in Economic Sciences, 4, pp. 159–176. doi:10.14595/PES/04/011.
Google Scholar

Koszel, M., Bartkowiak, P. (2018). Taksonomiczna miara zrównoważonego rozwoju obszarów metropolitalnych w Polsce [A taxonomic measure of sustainable development of metropolitan areas in Poland]. Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Ekonomicznego w Krakowie [Scientific Journals of Cracow University of Economics], 3(3(975)), pp. 83–100. doi:10.15678/znuek.2018.0975.0306.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Kuciński, K. (2015). Geografia ekonomiczna. Warszawa, Oficyna Wolters Kluwer Business.
Google Scholar

Laskowska, I., Dańska-Borsiak, B. (2018). Analiza przestrzennego zróżnicowania rozwoju społecznego
Google Scholar

w Polsce na poziomie NUTS 3 z wykorzystaniem lokalnego indeksu HDI [Analysis of spatial diversity of social development in Poland at NUTS 3 level with the use of local HDI index]. Acta Universitatis Lodziensis. Folia Oeconomica, 1(333), pp. 111–131. doi:10.18778/0208-6018.333.08.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Łogwiniuk, K. (2011). The use of taxonomic methods in the comparative analysis of the access to the ICT infrastructure by schoolchildren in Poland. Economy and Management, 1, pp. 7–23.
Google Scholar

Lu, D., Weng, Q. (2007). A survey of image classification methods and techniques for improving classification performance. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 28(5). doi:10.1080/01431160600746456.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Łuczak, A., Kurzawa, I. (2017). Assessment of the Level of Sustainable Development in Districts in Poland Using Taxonomic Methods. Prace Naukowe Uniwersytetu Ekonomicznego we Wrocławiu, 469, pp. 109–118. doi:10.15611/pn.2017.469.11.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Malina, A. (2020). Analiza przestrzennego zróżnicowania poziomu rozwoju społeczno-gospodarczego województw Polski w latach 2005–2017 [Analysis of spatial differentiation of the level of socio-economic development of Polish voivodeships in the years 2005–2017]. Social Inequalities and Economic Growth, 61(1), pp. 138–155. doi:10.15584/nsawg.2020.1.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Matras, A. (2017). Ranking społeczno-gospodarczy jednostek samorządu terytorialnego z uwzględnieniem poziomu zadłużenia oprocentowanego per capita [Socio-economic ranking of local government units taking into account the level of interest-bearing debt per capita]. Studia Ekonomiczne. Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Ekonomicznego w Katowicach [Economic Studies. Scientific Journals of the University of Economics in Katowice], 341, pp. 230–239.
Google Scholar

Michoń, D. (2017). Zróżnicowanie rozwoju społeczno-gospodarczego województw ze względu na realizację celów polityki spojności [Differentiation of socio-economic development of voivodeships in relations to the implementation of cohesion policy objectives]. Wiadomości Statystyczne [Statistical News], 12(679), pp. 80–94.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Mikuła, A. (2020). Level of Sustainable Development of Counties in Poland. Annals of the Polish Association of Agricultural and Agribusiness Economists, XXII(1), pp. 241–249. doi:10.5604/01.3001.0013.7792.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Misiewicz, E.I., Roszkowska, E., Rogowski, J. (2019). Ocena poziomu ładu gospodarczego województw Polski w 2015 r. [Assessment of the level of economic governance of Poland’s provinces in 2015]. Optimum. Economic Studies, 3(3(97)), pp. 3–18. doi:10.15290/oes.2019.03.97.01.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Moran, D.D., Wackernagel, M., Kitzes, J.A., Goldfinger, S.H., Boutaud, A. (2008). Measuring sustainable development – Nation by nation. Ecological Economics, 64(3). doi:10.1016/j.ecolecon.2007.08.017.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Moreno Pires, S., Fidelis, T., Ramos, T.B. (2014). Measuring and comparing local sustainable development through common indicators: Constraints and achievements in practice. Cities, 39. doi:10.1016/j.cities.2014.02.003.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Mori, K., Christodoulou, A. (2012). Review of sustainability indices and indicators: Towards a new City Sustainability Index (CSI). Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 32(1), pp. 94–106. doi:10.1016/j.eiar.2011.06.001.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Mortensen, L.F. (2013). Measuring sustainable development. In: Environmental Management in Practice: Instruments for Environmental Management. P., Compton, D., Devuyst, L., Hens, B., Nath (eds.). Londyn, Routledge.
Google Scholar

Morton, S., Pencheon, D., Squires, N. (2017). Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), and their implementation. British Medical Bulletin, 124. doi:10.1093/bmb/ldx031.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Niemczyk, A. (2001). Poziom rozwoju społecznego w nowym układzie administracyjnym Polski [The level of social development in the new administrative arrangement of Poland]. Przegląd Statystyczny [Statistical Review], 48(3–4), pp. 289–300.
Google Scholar

Nourry, M. (2008). Measuring sustainable development: Some empirical evidence for France from eight alternative indicators. Ecological Economics, 67(3). doi:10.1016/j.ecolecon.2007.12.019.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Nowak, E. (1990). Metody taksonomiczne w klasyfikacji obiektów społeczno-gospodarczych [Taxonomic methods in the classification of socio-economic objects]. Warszawa, PWE.
Google Scholar

Pearce, D., Hamilton, K., Atkinson, G. (1996). Measuring sustainable development: progress on indicators. Environment and Development Economics, 1(1). doi:10.1017/s1355770x00000395.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Podogrodzka, M. (2011). Analiza zjawisk społeczno-ekonomicznych z zastosowaniem metod taksonomicznych [Analysis of socio-economic phenomena using taxonomic methods]. Wiadomości Statystyczne [Statistical News], 11, pp. 26–41.
Google Scholar

Podstawka, M., Suchodolski, B. (2018). Assessment of the level of economic and social development of regions using the Hellwig taxonomic development measure. Proceedings of the 2018 VII International Scientific Conference Determinants of Regional Development, 1, pp. 187–201. doi:10.14595/CP/01/013.
Google Scholar

Polish National Register of Borders. (2020). http://www.gugik.gov.pl/pzgik/dane-bez-oplat/dane-z-panstwowego-rejestru-granic-i-powierzchni-jednostek-podzialow-terytorialnych-kraju-prg, date: 16.07.2020.
Google Scholar

Pomianek, I. (2010). Poziom rozwoju społeczno-gospodarczego obszarów wiejskich województwa warmińsko-mazurskiego [Level of Socio-Economic Development of Rural Areas in Warmińsko-Mazurskie Voivodeship]. Acta Scientiarum Polonorum Oeconomia, 9, pp. 227–239.
Google Scholar

Prus, B., Krol, K. (2017). Ocena zastosowania wybranych metod taksonomicznych do klasyfikacji zjawisk społeczno-gospodarczych [Evaluation of the application of selected taxonomic methods for classifying socio-economic phenomena]. Acta Scientiarum Polonorum Formatio Circumiectus, 16(2), pp. 179–197. doi:10.15576/ASP.FC/2017.16.2.179.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Rząsa, K., Ogryzek, M., Źrobek, R. (2019). The land transfer from the state treasury to local government units as a factor of social development of rural areas in Poland. Land, 8(11). doi:10.3390/land8110170.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Salamon, J. (2005). Badania wielofunkcyjnego rozwoju obszarów wiejskich województwa świętokrzyskiego [Studies on multifunctional development of rural areas in Świętokrzyskie voivodeship]. Infrastruktura i Ekologia Terenów Wiejskich [Infrastructure and Ecology of Rural Areas], 4, pp. 145–155.
Google Scholar

Schleicher-Tappeser, R. (2018). Sustainable development in the European Union – Monitoring Report on Progress Towards the SDGS in an EU Context. Greener Management International, 2001(36), pp. 50–66. doi:10.9774/gleaf.3062.2001.wi.00007.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Schober, P., Boer, C., Schwarte, L.A. (2018). Correlation coefficients: Appropriate use and interpretation. Anesthesia and Analgesia, 126(5), pp. 1763–1768. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000002864.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Senetra, A., Szarek-Iwaniuk, P. (2019). The implementation of the Wroclaw taxonomic method for the identification and evaluation of problem areas in the Warmia and Mazury Region in Poland – A case study. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences, 67, pp. 43–57. doi:10.1016/j.seps.2018.09.003.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Senetra, A., Szarek-Iwaniuk, P. (2020). Socio-economic development of small towns in the Polish Cittaslow Network – A case study. Cities, 103, p. 102758. doi:10.1016/j.cities.2020.102758.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Sharma, A., Tewari, R., Rana, S.S., Soni, R., Soni, S.K. (2016). Cellulases: Classification, Methods of Determination and Industrial Applications. Applied Biochemistry and Biotechnology, 179. doi:10.1007/s12010-016-2070-3.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Shen, L.Y., Jorge Ochoa, J., Shah, M.N., Zhang, X. (2011). The application of urban sustainability indicators – A comparison between various practices. Habitat International, 35(1), pp. 17–29. doi:10.1016/j.habitatint.2010.03.006.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Sołek, K., Sowa, B. (2019). Diversification of the Social Development of Podkarpackie Province Communes. Economic and Regional Studies / Studia Ekonomiczne i Regionalne, 12(1), pp. 45–55. doi:10.2478/ers-2019-0005.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Spangenberg, J.H. (2015). Indicators for sustainable development. In: Routledge International Handbook of Sustainable Development. M., Redclift, D., Springett (eds.). Londyn, Routledge.
Google Scholar

Stafford-Smith, M., Griggs, D., Gaffney, O., Ullah, F., Reyers, B., Kanie, N., Stigson, B., Shrivastava, P., Leach, M., O’Connell, D. (2017). Integration: the key to implementing the Sustainable Development Goals. Sustainability Science, 12. doi:10.1007/s11625-016-0383-3.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Stec, M. (2012). Analiza porównawcza rozwoju społeczno-gospodarczego powiatów województwa podkarpackiego [A comparative analysis of socio-economic development of powiats in Podkarpackie voivodeship]. Nierówności Społeczne a Wzrost Gospodarczy [Social Inequality and Economic Growth], 25, pp. 180–190.
Google Scholar

Sustainable Development Indicators. (2017). wskaznikizrp.stat.gov.pl, date 15.07.2020.
Google Scholar

Tanguay, G.A., Rajaonson, J., Lefebvre, J.F., Lanoie, P. (2010). Measuring the sustainability of cities: An analysis of the use of local indicators. Ecological Indicators, 10(2). doi:10.1016/j.ecolind.2009.07.013.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Tarka, D. (2010). Własności cech diagnostycznych w badaniach typu taksonomicznego [Properties of diagnostic features in taxonomic type studies]. Ekonomia i Zarządzanie [Economics and Management], 2(4), pp. 194–203.
Google Scholar

Tharwat, A. (2018). Classification assessment methods. Applied Computing and Informatics. doi:10.1016/j.aci.2018.08.003.
Crossref
Google Scholar

Toloie-Eshlaghy, A., Chitsaz, S., Karimian, L., Clarkhchi, R. (2011). A classification of qualitative research methods. Research Journal of International Studies, 20, pp. 106–123.
Google Scholar

United Nations. (2007). Indicators of Sustainable Development: Guidelines and Methodologies. New York, United Nations.
Google Scholar

United Nations. (2015). Sustainable Development Knowledge Plataform. https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/index.html, date: 16.07.2020.
Google Scholar

Urząd Statystyczny w Katowicach. (2018). Produkt krajowy brutto i wartość dodana brutto w przekroju regionów w 2016 r. [Gross domestic product and gross value added by region in 2016]. https://stat.gov.pl/download/gfx/portalinformacyjny/pl/defaultaktualnosci/5482/7/1/1/pkb_i_wartosc_dodana_brutto_w_przekroju_regionow_w_2016.pdf, date: 16.07.2020.
Google Scholar

World Commission on Environment and Development. (1987). Our Common Future. New York, Oxford University Press.
Google Scholar

Ziemiańczyk, U. (2010). Ocena poziomu rozwoju społeczno-gospodarczego gmin wiejskich i miejsko-wiejskich w województwie małopolskim [Evaluation of the level of socio-economic development of rural and urban-rural communes in the Małopolskie Voivodeship]. Infrastruktura i Ekologia Terenów Wiejskich [Infrastructure and Ecology of Rural Areas], 14, pp. 31–40.
Google Scholar