Влияние решений Замойского собора на формирование европейской ментальности в украинцев и белорусов Речи Посполитой – историография проблемы

Mykhailo Zhurba; Victor Dotsenko

doi:10.31648/ep.9298

Published: 2023-08-291

No. XXIV/1 (2023)

The influence of the decisions of the Synod of Zamość on the formation of the European mentality among Ukrainians and Byelorussians in the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth – historiography of the problem

Mykhailo Zhurba

, Victor Dotsenko

Echa Przeszłości

Section: ARTICLES

https://doi.org/10.31648/ep.9298

Abstract

The aim of the study was to analyze the historiography of the Greek Catholic Church before its reform, which was determined by the decisions of the Synod of Zamość in 1720 and unfolded against the background of aggravation of the geopolitical situation in Central and Eastern Europe. In scientific research, researchers rely on the main principles of historical science – objectivity and historicism.

Keywords:

Synod of Zamość, methodology, Uniate Church, historiography

Download files

pdf (Русский)

Citation rules

Zhurba, M., & Dotsenko, V. (2023). The influence of the decisions of the Synod of Zamość on the formation of the European mentality among Ukrainians and Byelorussians in the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth – historiography of the problem. Echa Przeszłości, (XXIV/1), 89–106. https://doi.org/10.31648/ep.9298

Cited by / Share

Licence

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

References

Antonovich P. (1909). Iz nedavnego proshlogo Volyini. VEV, 7, 12–28. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Antonovich V. (1871). Ocherk sostoyaniya pravoslavnoy tserkvi v Yugo-Zapadnoy Rossii po aktam (1650–1798). Kiev. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Antonovych V. (1991). Shcho prynesla Ukraini uniia. Vinnipeh. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Bila S.Ia. (2004). Uniini protsesy v zakhidnykh yeparkhiiakh Kyivskoi mytropolii (ostannia tretyna KhVII – pochatok KhVIII st.). Istoriohrafiia problemy. Avtoref. … dys. k.i.n. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Chistovich I.A. (1884). Ocherk istorii zapadnorusskoy tserkvi. T. 2. SPb. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Gurevich A.Ya. (1991). O krizise sovremennoy istoricheskoy nauki. Voprosyi istorii, 2-3. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Hoynatskiy A.O. (1871). Zapadnorusskaya tserkovnaya uniya v ee bogosluzhenii i obryadah. Kiev. []
Google Scholar

Hrushevskyi M.S. (1990). Iliustrovana istoriia Ukrainy. Repryntne vidtvorennia vydannia 1913 r. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Hrustsevich G. (1880). Istoriya Zamoyskogo sobora (1720 goda). Vilno. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Karamzin N.M. (1816-1829). Istoriya gosudarstva Rossiyskogo. T. 12. Moskva–SPb. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Karamzin N.M. (1862). Mnenie russkogo grazhdanina. Neizdannyie sochineniya i perepiska N.M. Karamzina. Sankt-Peterburg. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Kareev N.I. (1886). Ocherk istorii reformatsionnogo dvizheniya i katolicheskoy reaktsii v Polshe. Moskva. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Kareev N.I. (1888). «Padeniya Polshi» v istoricheskoy literature. Moskva. [[in Russian]
Google Scholar

Khikhlach B. (2011). Istoriia vasylianskykh monastyriv na Bratslavshchyni (KhVIII – i tretyna KhIKh st.). Arkhiv Ukrainskoi Tserkvy, Seriia I. Doslidzhennia. Vypusk I. Istoriia unii na Kyivshchyni 1596 –1839 rokiv. Lviv. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Khikhlach B.M. (2010). Uniatska tserkva na Podilli v ukrainskomu sotsiokulturnomu protsesi XVIII st. (Candidate’s thesis). Kyiv. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Klyuchevskiy V.O. (1913). Ocherki i rechi. Moskva. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Kostomarov N. (1841). O prichinah i haraktere unii v Zapadnoy Rossii. Harkov. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Kruchkovskiy T.T. (2018). Istoriya Polshi v kontseptsiyah Rossiyskoy istoriografii HIH – nachala HH veka. Avtoref. dis. d.i.n. Minsk. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Kryzhanivskyi O.P., Plokhii S.M. (1994) Istoriia tserkvy ta relihiinoi dumky v Ukraini: navch. posibnyk: u 3-kh kn. Kn. 3. Kinets XVI – seredyna KhIKh st. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Los V.E. (2013). Uniatska Tserkva na Pravoberezhnii Ukraini nap-rykintsi XVIII – pershii polovyni KhIKh st.: orhanizatsiina struktura ta kulturno-relihiinyi aspekt. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Luzhnytskyi H. (1954). Ukrainska Tserkva mizh Skhodom i Zakhodom: Narys istorii Ukrainskoi Tserkvy. Filadelfiia. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Narys istorii Vasyliianskoho Chynu Sviatoho Yosafata. (1992). Rym. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Nedavnia O.V. (1999). Hreko-katolytsyzm v konteksti dukhovnoho samovyznachennia ukraintsiv mizh khrystyianskym Skhodom i Zakhodom. (Candidate’s thesis). Kyiv. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Nedelskiy S. (1893). Uniatskiy mitropolit Lev Kishka i ego znachenie v istorii Unii. Vilno. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Novakovskyi P. (2018). Zamoiskyi Synod 1720 roku v tserkovnomu ta suspilno-politychnomu zhytti Ukrainy. Visnyk ahrarnoi istorii, 25–26, 9–16. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Novitskaya-Ezhova A. (1996). Orden bazilian i ego kulturno-prosvetitelskaya deyatelnost na ukrainsko-belorussko-litovskih zemlyah Rechi Pospolitoy. Slavyanovedenie, 2, 33–46. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Onyshchuk S.V. (2014). Mekhanizmy vplyvu Zamoiskoho synodu na derzhavotvorchi protsesy v Ukraini. Naukovyi visnyk Akademii munitsypalnoho upravlinnia. Seriia «Upravlinnia», 2. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Peregovskiy B. (1880). Otryivok iz istorii prisoedineniya na Volyine uniatov k pravoslaviyu v tsarstvovanie Ekaterinyi II i Pavla I. VEV, 2. – S. 70–78. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Petrov N. (1868). Kratkie izvestiya o polozhenii bazilianskogo ordena i raznyih peremenah v ego upravlenii. Trudyi KDA, 5, 428–434. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Pidlypczak-Majerowicz М. (1998). Szkoly Iksiazki w dzialalnosci bazylianow w XVII-XVIII wieku na ziemiach polsko-litewsko-ruskich. Chrzescijanin w swiecie. Zeszyty OdiS, 179–180 (8–9), 190–207. [in Poland]
Google Scholar

Salamakha M. (2013). Vasylianski monastyri yak oseredky relihiinoi identychnosti ukraintsiv (ostannia chvert KhVIII st. – 30-ti roky KhIKh st.). Naukovyi visnyk Skhidnoievropeiskoho natsionalnoho universytetu imeni Lesi Ukrainky. Vyp. 21. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Schebalskiy P. (1864). Russkaya politika i russkaya partiya v Polshe do Ekaterinyi II. Moskva. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Senyk C. (1993). Ukrainska Tserkva v KhVII st. Kovcheh. Zbirnyk statei z tserkovnoi istorii. T. 1. Lviv. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Sheretiuk R.M. (2012). Stanovyshche hreko-uniatskoi tserkvy naperedodni podiliv Rechi Pospolytoi. Aktualni problemy vitchyznianoi ta vsesvitnoi istorii. Zbirnyk naukovykh prats Rivnenskoho derzhavnoho humanitarnoho universytetu. Vyp. 23, 29–39. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Sheretiuk R.M. (2013). Instytutsiini transformatsii hreko-uniatskoi tserkvy v konteksti etnokonfesiinoi polityky rosiiskoho samoderzhavstva (1772–1795 rr.). Ukrainske relihiieznavstvo. 66, 171–180. [in Ukrainian]
Crossref
Google Scholar

Sheretiuk V. (2002). Pravoslavna tserkva Pravoberezhnoi Ukrainy u konteksti politychnykh vidnosyn Rosii i Rechi Pospolytoi kintsia XVII–XVIII st. (Candidate’s thesis).Kyiv. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Shkrabiuk P.V. (2005). Monashyi Chyn Ottsiv Vasylian u natsionalnomu zhytti Ukrainy. Lviv. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Shkribliak M. (2010). Stanovyshche pravoslavia na Pravoberezhnii Ukraini u postberesteiskyi period i prychyny perekhodu Zakhidno-ukrainskykh yeparkhii na uniiu z Rymom. Relihiia ta Sotsium. 1(3). [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Simashkevich M. (1878). Rimskoe katolichestvo i ego ierarhiya v Podolii. Kamyanets-Podolsk. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Sitsinskiy Yu. (1889). K istorii unii v Podolii. VEV, 20, 433–445. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Skinner B. (2009). The Western front Eastern Church: Uniate and Orthodox Conflict in 18th – century: Poland, Ukraint, Belarus, and Russia. DeKalb. [in English]
Google Scholar

Skochylias I. (2010). Halytska (Lvivska) yeparkhiia XII–XVIII stolit: orhanizatsiina struktura ta pravovyi status. Lviv. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Skochylias I. (2017). Osoblyvosti istoriopysannia kyivskoho khrystyianstva. Radianski realii, diasporna intehratsiia ta ukrainska reabilitatsiia. Ukraina: kulturna spadshchyna, natsionalna svidomist, derzhavnist. 29. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Skochylias I. (2020). Instrumentalizuiuchy mynule: Ekleziialna, istorychna y kulturna pamʼiat pro Zamoiskyi sobor (kinets XVIII – persha polovyna XX stolit)[Elektronnyi resurs] https://ucu.edu.ua/events/instrumentalizuyuchy-mynule-ekleziyalna-istorychna-j-kulturna-pam-yat-pro-zamojskyj-sobor-kinets-xviii-persha-polovyna-xx-stolit/ [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Solovev C.B. (2010). Izbrannoe. Moskva. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Solovev C.M. (1863). Istoriya padeniya Polshi. Moskva. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Solovev C.M. (1992). Pisma A.A. Kireevu. Simvol, 27. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Statuty Synodu Zamojskiego 1720 roku. Nowe tlumaczenie z komentarzami. (2020). Krakow. [in Poland]
Google Scholar

Sviatenko A. (2009). Hreko-Katolytska i Rymo-Katolytska tserkvy v osvitianskii politytsi samoderzhavstva na Pravoberezhnii Ukraini (kinets KhVIII – persha polovyna KhIKh st. Kyivska starovyna, 5–6. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Teodorovich H. (1889). Istoriko-statisticheskoe opisanie tserkvey i prihodov Volyinskoy eparhii. Pochaev. [in Russian]
Google Scholar

Vavryk M. (1979). Narys rozvytku i stanu Vasylianskoho Chyna KhVII – KhKh st. Topohrafichno-statystychna rozvidka. Rym. [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar

Yakovenko H. (2006). Narys istorii serednovichnoi ta rannomodernoi Ukrainy. Kyiv [in Ukrainian]
Google Scholar