Eastern and Central European ethnicism in light of Western studies on nation and nationalism
Jacek Poniedziałek
Nicolaus Copernicus University in ToruńAbstrakt
The aim of this article is to critically analyze the binary concept of civic nations represented by the civic communities of Western Europe and ethnic groups living in Central and Eastern Europe. The works of Ernest Gellner and John Breuilly were selected for research because they have used the indicated concept in their texts, and have become an inspiration for many researchers of national issues. The former represents a deterministic trend of sociological inquiries, the latter – social constructivism. Due to the above, they are representative examples of academic reflection on national issues widespread in Western European thought. The research proposes to reject the binary model in which civil nations were characterized as rational and striving for consensus communities and ethnic groups as irrational communities striving for conflict. The analytical model characterizing nations as political and ethnic communities was proposed instead of it.
Słowa kluczowe:
civil and ethnic nations, nations of Central and Eastern Europe, Ernest Gellner, John Breuilly, studies on nation and nationalismBibliografia
ANTONSICH, M. (2015), Nations and nationalism. In: Agnew, A. J. (ed.), The Wiley Blackwell Companion to Political Geography. Oxford, 297-310.
Crossref
Google Scholar
BÖHLER, J. (2018), Wojna domowa. Nowe spojrzenie na odrodzenie Polski. Kraków. Google Scholar
BORODZIEJ, W. | GÓRNY, M. (2018), Nasza wojna. Narody 1917-1923, T. II. Warszawa. Google Scholar
BREUILLY, J. (1996), The Formation of the First German Nation State, 1800-1871. Basingstoke.
Crossref
Google Scholar
BREUILLY, J. (2003), Was Prussian victory over Austria in 1866 inevitable? In: Modern History Students. 1 (9), 6-10. Google Scholar
BREUILLY, J. (2009), Risorgimento nationalism in the light of general debates about nationalism. In: Nations and Nationalism. 3 (15), 439-445.
Crossref
Google Scholar
BREUILLY, J. (2013), Nationalism and national unification in 19th century Europe. In: Breuilly, J. (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of the History of Nationalism. Oxford, 149-175.
Crossref
Google Scholar
BREUILLY, J. (2015), Nations and nation-states in history. In: Wright, D. J. (ed.), International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences. Oxford, 297-303.
Crossref
Google Scholar
BREUILLY, J. (2016), Benedict Anderson’s imagined communities: a symposium. In: Nations and Nationalism, 22 (4), 625-659
Crossref
Google Scholar
BREUILLY, J. (2017), Modern empires and nation-states. In: Thesis Eleven. 139 (1), 11-29.
Crossref
Google Scholar
D`AURIA, M. (2020), The Shaping French National Identity. Cambridge.
Crossref
Google Scholar
DERA, A. (2020), Kampania i przebieg plebiscytu z 11 lipca 1920 roku na Warmii i Mazurach w świetle mate-riałów tekstowych oraz ikonograficznych zamieszczonych w lokalnej prasie niemieckojęzyczne. In: Echa Przeszłości. 1 (XXI), 239-260.
Crossref
Google Scholar
FICHTE, G. J. (1996), Zamknięte państwo handlowe i inne pisma. Warszawa. Google Scholar
GREENFELD, L. (2019), Nationalism: a short history. Washington DC. Google Scholar
GELLNER, E. (1964), Thought and Change. London. Google Scholar
GELLNER, E. (1996), The coming of nationalism and its interpretation: the myths of nation and class. In: Bala-krishnan, G. (ed.), Mapping the Nation. London, 98-145. Google Scholar
GELLNER, E. (1998), Language and Solitude: Wittgenstein, Malinowski and the Habsburg Dilemma. Cambridge.
Crossref
Google Scholar
GELLNER, E. (2009), Narody i nacjonalizm. Warszawa. Google Scholar
HEGEL, G. (1958), Wykłady z filozofii dziejów. Vol. 1. Warszawa. Google Scholar
HERDER, F. (1962), Myśli o filozofii dziejów. Warszawa. Google Scholar
KERR, W. (2019), The descent of nations: social evolutionary theory, modernism and ethno-symbolism. In: Nations and Nationalism. 1 (25), 104-123.
Crossref
Google Scholar
KŁOSKOWSKA, A. (2005), Kultury narodowe u korzeni. Warszawa. Google Scholar
KOHN, H. (1944), The Idea of Nationalizm. New York. Google Scholar
KURINA, A. T. (2020), State Boundaries in the Minds of Men: Bulgarian Intellectuals Dividing the Balkans in the Mid-19th Century. In: Colloquia Humanistica. 8, 17-36.
Crossref
Google Scholar
MEINECKE, F. (1928), Weltbürgertum und Nationalstaat: Studien zur Genesis der deutschen Nationalstaates. München – Berlin. Google Scholar
MUCHA, J. (2009), Socjologia w Europie Środkowo-Wschodniej czy socjologia wschodnioeuropejska? In: Prze-gląd Socjologiczny. 2 (58), 9-31. Google Scholar
MURRAY, J. P. (2018), The archipelagic turn: nationhood, nationalism and early modern studies. In: The Seven-theenth Century. 4 (33), 485-495.
Crossref
Google Scholar
OPALIŃSKI, E. (2004), Obywatel i państwo: Wokół Rzeczypospolitej Obojga Narodów In: Przegląd Polityczny. 67-68, 104-112. Google Scholar
OSTERHAMMEL, J. (2013), Historia XIX wieku. Przeobrażenie świata. Poznań. Google Scholar
PONIEDZIAŁEK, J. (2018), Problematyka narodu w pismach klasyków myśli socjologicznej. Toruń. Google Scholar
RADZIK, R. (2016), Rosyjska wizja narodu ogólnorosyjskiego. In: Studia Białorutenistyczne. 10, 55-76.
Crossref
Google Scholar
ROMAN, N. (2020), Educating the Other Foreign Governesses in Wallachia in the First Half of the Nineteenth Century. In: Apasia. 1 (14), 37-56.
Crossref
Google Scholar
SIMA, M. (2019), Geopolityczne znaczenie idei Wielkich Węgier. In: Przegląd Geopolityczny. 28, 9-30. Google Scholar
SMITH, A. (1998), Nationalism and Modernism. London. Google Scholar
SMITH, A. (2007), Nacjonalizm. Warszawa. Google Scholar
SMITH, A. (2009), Ethno-symbolism and Nationalism: A Cultural Approach. London.
Crossref
Google Scholar
TODOROVA, M. (2008), Bałkany wyobrażone. Warszawa. Google Scholar
Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń
