Institutional audit of professional military education: a way to quality assurance according to Nato standards

Volodymyr Mirnenko

Vadym Artamoshchenko

Stasys Paldunas


The article highlights the obtained results on conducting an institutional audit of the professional
military education system in educational institutions of the Ministry of Defence and the Armed
Forces of Ukraine. The directions of further development of institutional audit mechanisms for
evaluation of professional military education quality on the way to achieving compatibility of training
processes according to NATO standards were substantiated. The results of the experiment confirm
that institutional audit is a common element on the way to achieve compatibility of personnel
training processes on NATO quality principles. The authors of the article use a system of general
scientific and special methods of theoretical and empirical research (systematization, generalization,
systematic approach) and methods of expert evaluation.

Słowa kluczowe:

professional military education, institutional audit, educational program, quality

Artamoshchenko V.S., Favorska O.U. Management of changes in the development of the military education system based on program and project management. Science and defense, 2019 (2). pp. 40–44.   Google Scholar

BI-Strategic Command Directive 075-007 / Education and Individual Training Directive. (2015 September 10).   Google Scholar

Decree of the President of Ukraine № 392/2020. On the national security strategy of Ukraine. (2020 September 15).   Google Scholar

Developing Today’s Joint Officers for Tomorrow’s Ways of War. / The Joint Chiefs of Staff Vision and Guidance for Professional Military Education & Talent Management. (2020 May 01). vision.pdf?ver= 2020-05-15-102429-817.   Google Scholar

Dudka Т. Modern institutional audit of educational establishments: transmission of value orientations. Mountain School of Ukrainian Carpaty, 2020 (22), pp. 9–13.   Google Scholar

Law of Ukraine On education № 2145-VIII. (2017 September 5).   Google Scholar

Law of Ukraine On higher education № 1556-VII. (2014 July 1). https://zakon.rada.   Google Scholar

Order of the Ministry of Defence of Ukraine. On the organization of the implementation of certain measures of defence reform in the medium term № 283. (2020 August 14).   Google Scholar

Order of the Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine. On approval of the Procedure for carrying out institutional audit of establishments of general secondary education № 17. (2019 February 09).   Google Scholar

Order of the Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine. Regulations on the accreditation of educational programs, which provide training for higher education №977. (2019 July 11).   Google Scholar

Poltorak S.T. Transformation of Ukraine's military education system on the way to achieving NATO standards. Science and defence, 2018 (2), pp. 3–10.   Google Scholar

Punda U.V. Education is the main investment in the development of human capital in the security and defense sector of Ukraine. Science and defense, 2018 (1), pp. 34–40.   Google Scholar

Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine. On approval of the Regulations on accreditation of higher education institutions and specialties in higher education institutions and higher vocational schools № 978. (2001 August 9).   Google Scholar

Viter D., Mitiahin О. Professionalization of military education in Ukraine: main directions, content and prospects. Military education: Collection of scientific works NDU. 2020 (1), pp. 81–90.   Google Scholar

Vorobiova О., Debych М., Luhovyi V., Orzhel О., Sliusarenko О., Talanova Zh, Tryma К. Assessing the quality of higher education in the context of European integration: guidelines. Kyiv. Instytut vyshchoi osvity NAPNU. 2019.   Google Scholar



Cited By /

Mirnenko, V., Artamoshchenko, V., & Paldunas, S. (2021). Institutional audit of professional military education: a way to quality assurance according to Nato standards . Civitas Et Lex, 32(4), 7–21.

Volodymyr Mirnenko 

Vadym Artamoshchenko 

Stasys Paldunas 


Wszystkie artykuły opublikowane w Civitas et Lex są dostępne online w trybie otwartego dostępu (Open Access) i można je pobrać bezpłatnie na podstawie następującej licencji Creative Commons CC BY-NC-ND (Attribution – Non-Commercial – No Derivative Works) 4.0.