Published: 2026-10-11

The Vicious Circle of Understanding. Conspiracy Theories as a Hermeneutics of Distrust

Ewa Kozik
Media - Culture - Social Communication
Section: Articles
https://doi.org/10.31648/mcsc.11575

Conspiracy Theories as a Hermeneutics of Distrust

Abstract

This article addresses the presence of conspiracy theories in public discourse as a manifestation of the so-called “hermeneutics of suspicion” and analyzes their operation in the context of Hans-Georg Gadamer’s philosophy and Jerzy Bartmiński’s concept of the linguistic worldview. It begins by highlighting Gadamer’s view of hermeneutics as an event of understanding rooted in language, historicity, and dialogue, which provides insight into the interpretive mechanisms used by both creators and recipients of conspiratorial narratives. Against this backdrop, the article examines a specific example of online polemics between the report of the Polish Government’s Disinformation Task Force and a critical article published on the “WolneMedia” portal, identifying rhetorical strategies employed therein (e.g., irony, counterexample, delegitimization of institutions) that enhance the emotional impact of the message and align with a hermeneutics of suspicion. Juxtaposing these elements with the notion of linguistic worldview reveals how alternative media shape the cognitive reality of their audiences. The article concludes with a reflection on the risks of being trapped in a hermeneutic circle of distrust and fact denial, and argues for the epistemic superiority of institutional knowledge over conspiratorial thinking. It also proposes an interpretive framework for diagnosing a society dominated by suspicion and alternative epistemologies.

Keywords:

cultural anthropology, conspiracy theories, hermeneutics, alternative media, trust

Citation rules

Kozik, E. (2026). The Vicious Circle of Understanding. Conspiracy Theories as a Hermeneutics of Distrust: Conspiracy Theories as a Hermeneutics of Distrust. Media - Culture - Social Communication, (22). https://doi.org/10.31648/mcsc.11575

Cited by / Share

This website uses cookies for proper operation, in order to use the portal fully you must accept cookies.