Do regulatory stringency and household indebtedness affect financial stability? An analysis of the market for non-bank lending institutions in selected Central and Eastern European countries

Amby Legal (2024), What you need to know about consumer lending, [in:] https://ambylegal.by/ news/what-you-need-to-know-about-consumer-lending/ (accessed: 02.06.2024).   Google Scholar

BNB – Bulgarian National Bank (2024), Overview of the macroprudential measures introduced by the BNB to address the risks to the banking system, [in:] https://www.bnb.bg/bnbweb/groups/ public/documents/bnb_download/bs_mpp_overview_en.pdf (accessed: 22.06.2024).   Google Scholar

BOL – Bank of Lithuania (2024), Consumer credit providers, [in:] https://www.lb.lt/en/consumer-credit-providers-1 (accessed: 21.05.2024).   Google Scholar

BRSA – Banking Regulation and Supervision Agency (2013), Regulation on principles for establishment and operations of financial leasing, factoring and financing companies, Official Gazette 28627, [in:] https://www.cbfo.gov.tr/sites/default/files/docs/2021-06/regulationofestablisment_fkb_-en. pdf (accessed: 08.07.2024).   Google Scholar

Bublienė, D. (2014), The future of consumer credit in Lithuania: Quo vadis consumer credit? In: Juridica International 12, 149-167. DOI: 10.12697/JI.2014.22.12   Google Scholar

Cole, M. (2023), Audit Office: Consumer loan sector needs more effective supervision, ERR news, [in:] https://news.err.ee/1609030394/audit-office-consumer-loan-sector-needs-more-effective-supervision (accessed: 25.06.2024).   Google Scholar

Consumer Credit Act (2024), Ustawa z dnia 12 maja 2011 r. o kredycie konsumenckim, Dz.U. 2011 nr 126, poz. 715 z późn. zm.   Google Scholar

Csajbok, A. | Dadashova, P. | Shykin, P. et al. (2020), Consumer lending in Ukraine: estimation of the equilibrium level, [in:] Visnyk of the National Bank of Ukraine 249, 4-12, [in:] https:// journal.bank.gov.ua/uploads/articles/249-1.pdf (accessed: 15.07.2024).   Google Scholar

Dancausa, F. | Melecky, M. (2024), New beginnings: Resolving consumer insolvencies in Central Asia. World Bank, [in:] https://blogs.worldbank.org/en/psd/new-beginnings-resolving-consumer-insolvencies-central-asia (accessed: 10.07.2024).   Google Scholar

EC – European Commission (2020), Romania, [in:] https://commission.europa.eu/document/ download/64675a85-834d-4494-97f3-dbf37da089cc_en?filename=romania_country_fich_ en.pdf (accessed: 18.05.2024).   Google Scholar

ECB – European Central Bank (2020), Bulgaria – assessment of ERM II prior commitment No. 2 on the macroprudential toolkit, [in:] https://www.ecb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/other/ecb_assessment_ bulgaria_erm_II~42b06fb4e2.en.pdf (accessed: 22.06.2024)   Google Scholar

ECCR – European Consumer Centre Romania (2024), Consumer credit, [in:] https://eccromania. ro/language/en/topics/consumer-credit/ (accessed: 17.07.2024)   Google Scholar

EMN – European Microfinance Network (2016), EMN Legislative Mapping Report. Bulgaria, [in:] https://www.european-microfinance.org/sites/default/files/document/file/bulgaria.pdf (accessed: 09.07.2024).   Google Scholar

EMN – European Microfinance Network (2019a), EMN Legislative Mapping Report. Romania, [in:] https://www.european-microfinance.org/sites/default/files/document/file/romania2.pdf (accessed: 21.07.2024).   Google Scholar

EMN – European Microfinance Network (2019b), EMN Legislative Mapping Report. Bulgaria, [in:] https://www.european-microfinance.org/sites/default/files/document/file/bulgaria_0.pdf (accessed: 21.07.2024).   Google Scholar

EMN – European Microfinance Network (2023), Microcredit regulation in Europe: An overview, [in:] https://www.european-microfinance.org/sites/default/files/document/file/mainReport_NEW%20 %281%29.pdf (accessed: 29.05.2024).   Google Scholar

Erbilen, M. | Yamakoğlu, M. | Harmanşa, A. A. (2024), Digital banking versus traditional banking in Türkiye: the legal considerations for consumer protection, International Bar Association, [in:] https://www.ibanet.org/digital-banking-versus-traditional-banking-in-turkiye-legal-considerations-for-consumer-protection (accessed: 09.07.2024).   Google Scholar

ESRB – European Systemic Risk Board (2019), Template for notifying national macroprudential measures not covered by CRR/CRD, [in:] https://www.esrb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/other/esrb. notification190116_other_ro.en.pdf (accessed: 28.07.2024).   Google Scholar

ESRB – European Systemic Risk Board (2024), National measures of macropruden¬tial interest in the EU/EEA, [in:] https://www.google.pl/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&es¬r c = s & s o u r c e = we b & c d = & c a d = r j a & u a c t = 8 & ve d = 2 a hU K Ew jJ sM K M 3b i H A x¬WoA 9sEH UqSA aUQFnoECC o QAQ& u rl=ht t p s%3A%2F%2Fw w w.e s r b.e u r op a . eu%2Fnational_policy%2Fshared%2Fpdf%2Fesrb.measures_overview_macroprudential_meas-ures.xlsx&usg=AOvVaw1nqEuI1H3KzXM2gp7qft_k&opi=89978449 (accessed: 19.06.2024).   Google Scholar

EU – European Union (2023), Directive (EU) 2023/2225 of the European Parliament and of the Coun¬cil of 18 October 2023 on credit agreements for consumers and repealing Directive 2008/48/EC   Google Scholar

EU – European Union (2008), Directive 2008/48/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 April 2008 on credit agreements for consumers and repealing Council Directive 87/102/EEC   Google Scholar

Fitch Ratings (2023), Turkish NBFIs’ Funding Profiles Remain Under Pressure Post-Election, [in:] https://www.fitchratings.com/research/non-bank-financial-institutions/turkish-nbfis-funding-profiles-remain-under-pressure-post-election-05-06-2023 (accessed: 10.07.2023).   Google Scholar

FLA – Finance & Leasing Association (2024), What is consumer finance? In: https://www.fla.org. uk/about-us/faqs/what-is-consumer-finance/ (accessed: 04.05.2024).   Google Scholar

FRRF (2022), Analysis of non-bank consumer credit markets in the European Union, [in:] https:// www.frrf.pl (accessed: 24.04.2024).   Google Scholar

Gattini, L. | Borysko, S. (2018), Republic of Belarus. Financial Sector Review and Private Sector Financing, EIB, [in:] https://www.eib.org/attachments/efs/republic_of_belarus_financial_sector_ review_en.pdf (accessed: 02.07.2024).   Google Scholar

Gębski, Ł. (2022), Regulacje konsumenckie i ochrona konsumenta na rynku usług finansowych, [in:] Waliszewski, K. (red.), Finanse osobiste. Warszawa, 303-314.   Google Scholar

Gusmanova, Z. | Kurmanalina, А. (2023), Development of consumer lending in the Republic of Kazakhstan: negative and positive aspects, [in:] ECONOMIC Series of the Bulletin of the L N Gumilyov ENU 1, 118-128, [in:] https://bulecon.enu.kz/index.php/main/article/view/131 (accessed: 02.08.2024)   Google Scholar

Hudima, T. | Ustymenko, V. | Dzhabrailov, R. et al. (2024), Consumer lending vs ludomania: From resilience to social responsibility in the case of Ukraine, [in:] Journal of Eastern European and Central Asian Research (JEECAR) 11 (2), 394-408.   Google Scholar

Iacob, E. (2016), New regulations for consumer credit in Romania, [in:] https://www.lexology.com/ library/detail.aspx?g=523d4439-43c2-45e8-8cf9-4494dbb69bde (accessed: 03.07.2024)   Google Scholar

ICLG (2024), Consumer Protection Laws and Regulations Romania 2024, [in:] https://iclg.com/ practice-areas/consumer-protection-laws-and-regulations/romania (accessed: 10.06.2024)   Google Scholar

IMF – International Monetary Fund (2020), Georgia. Technical assistance report––strengthen regulation, supervision, and oversight of micro lending institutions, [in:] https://www.imf.org/ en/Publications/CR/Issues/2020/09/03/Georgia-Technical-Assistance-Report-Strengthening- Regulation-Supervision-and-Oversight-of-49728 (accessed: 04.07.2024).   Google Scholar

IMF – International Monetary Fund (2022), Republic of Moldova. IMF Country Report No. 22/320, [in:] https://www.imf.md/press/SR_2022_1MDAEA2022006.pdf (accessed: 01.07.2024).   Google Scholar

IMF – International Monetary Fund (2024), Republic of Kazakhstan: Financial System Stability Assessment, [in:] https://www.elibrary.imf.org/view/journals/002/2024/048/article-A001-en.xml (accessed: 26.07.2024).   Google Scholar

IMF – International Monetary Fund. European Dept. (2023), Republic of Moldova: Second Reviews Under the Extended Credit Facility and Extended Fund Facility Arrangements, and Request for Waiver of Applicability for Performance Criteria-Press Release; Staff Report; and Statement by the Executive Director for Republic of Moldova. IMF Staff Country Reports, 2023(006), A001.   Google Scholar

InfoMarket (2022), From September 1, non-bank credit institutions must apply the requirements for responsible lending, 24 June 2022, [in:] https://infomarket.md/en/businesslaw/290099/ (accessed: 01.07.2024).   Google Scholar

ING (2023), Turkey: Another soft cap on personal need loans, [in:] https://think.ing.com/snaps/ turkey-another-soft-cap-on-personal-need-loans/ (accessed: 19.05.2024).   Google Scholar

Ivashchenko, A. | Horodetska, T. | Meleshkevich, S. (2021), Overview of the current state of consumer lending in commercial banks of Ukraine and its organizational and economic support, [in:] Economics. Finances. Law. 12, 22-28.   Google Scholar

Kandemir, A. | Ozsoy, T. (2023), Turkey is Pushing Lenders to Cut Rates on Consumer Loans, [in:] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-10/turkey-government-pushing-lenders-to-cut-rates-on-consumer-loans (accessed: 09.07.2024).   Google Scholar

KPMG (2019), NBR restricts debt-to-income ratio for loans from 1 January 2019, [in:] https://kpmg. com/ro/en/home/insights/2019/01/debt-to-income-ratio-loans-2019-restricted.html (accessed: 11.07.2024).   Google Scholar

Kumenov, A. (2023), Kazakhstan: Government tackles personal debt mountain, but not everyone is happy, [in:] https://eurasianet.org/kazakhstan-government-tackles-personal-debt-mountain-but-not-everyone-is-happy (accessed: 10.07.2024)   Google Scholar

Labanava, Y. (2018), Consumer loans of Belarusians could cause economic catastrophe, [in:] https:// belsat.eu/en/news/consumer-loans-of-belarusians-could-cause-economic-catastrophe (accessed: 02.07.2024)   Google Scholar

Lehmann, A. (2019), Regulation of the micro-finance sector in Moldova, [in:] https://www.german-economic-team.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/PB_01_2019_en.pdf (accessed: 16.05.2024)   Google Scholar

Mazure, G. (2017), Non-bank consumer crediting trends in Latvia, [in:] Research for rural development. 2, 276-283.   Google Scholar

MG LAW (2023), Introducing Microbanks – New Financial Institution in Georgia, [in:] https:// mglaw.ge/2023/06/09/introducing-microbanks-new-financial-institution-in-georgia/ (accessed: 14.07.2024)   Google Scholar

Molodyko, K. (2018), Regulatory choices of Russian and Ukrainian legislators in consumer credits: a comparative perspective, [in:] Russian Law Journal. 6, 100-125.   Google Scholar

Monahov, A. (2022), The DSTI Gap: Measuring the Impact of An Inflationary Shock on Borrowers’ Repayment Capacity in 14 European Economies, [in:] https://ssrn.com/abstract=4089856 or http:// dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4089856 (accessed: 28.09.2024).   Google Scholar

NBG – National Bank of Georgia (2016), National strategy for financial education in Georgia. Financial literacy for financial well-being, [in:] national-strategy-for-financial-education-of-georgia-2023.pdf (nbg.gov.ge) (accessed: 03.08.2024).   Google Scholar

NBG – National Bank of Georgia (2018), Order # 143/04 of 5 July 2018 of the President of the National Bank of Georgia on Approval of Regulation on Supervision and Regulation of Microfinance Organization Activities   Google Scholar

NBG – National Bank of Georgia (2021), Order of the President of the National Bank of Georgia No. 32/04 of 9 March 2021 on the approval of principles for the protection of consumer rights in the provision of services by financial organisations.   Google Scholar

NBG – National Bank of Georgia (2023), Financial Stability Report 2023, [in:] https://nbg.gov.ge/ en/publications/financial-stability-reports (accessed: 04.06.2024).   Google Scholar

NBM – National Bank of Moldova (2023), Financial stability report for 2022, [in:] https://www. bnm.md/files/RSF_2022_EN_v1.pdf (accessed: 01.07.2024).   Google Scholar

NBP – National Bank of Poland (2024), Financial stability report. June 2024, [in:] https://nbp.pl/ wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Raport-o-stabilnosci-systemu-finansowego.-Czerwiec-2024-EN. pdf (accessed: 28.09.2024).   Google Scholar

NBR – National Bank of Romania (2023), Financial Stability Report, December 2023, [in:] https:// www.bnr.ro/PublicationDocuments.aspx?icid=19968 (accessed: 18.07.2024)   Google Scholar

NBU – National Bank of Ukraine (2024a), Financial Stability Report. June 2024, [in:] https://bank. gov.ua/admin_uploads/article/FSR_2024-H1_eng.pdf?v=7 (accessed: 16.07.2024).   Google Scholar

NBU – National Bank of Ukraine (2024b), Macroprudential Policy Strategy of the National Bank of Ukraine, [in:] https://bank.gov.ua/en/stability/macro#71-strategic-documents (accessed: 27.07.2024).   Google Scholar

Niedziółka, P. (2009), Kredytowe instrumenty pochodne a stabilność finansowa. Warszawa.   Google Scholar

Nurbayev, D. (2016), Consumer lending in Kazakhstan. Eurasian Research Institute, [in:] Weekly e-bulletin 79, [in:] https://eurasian-research.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Weekly-e-bulletin- 30.08.2016-05.09.2016-No-79.pdf (accessed: 19.07.2024).   Google Scholar

Prime Minister of the Republic of Kazakhstan (2023), Kazakhstan works out legislative amendments to strengthen protection of creditors rights, [in:] https://primeminister.kz/en/news/kazakhstan-works-out-legislative-amendments-to-strengthen-protection-of-creditors-rights-26105 (accessed: 10.07.2024).   Google Scholar

Riigikogu (2016), Creditors and Credit Intermediaries Act, [in:] https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/ eli/523122021001/consolide (accessed: 24.07.2024).   Google Scholar

Santoso, W. | Sukada, M. (2009), Risk profile of households and the impact on financial stability, [in:] BIS Papers chapters, Bank for International Settlements (ed.), Household debt: implications for monetary policy and financial stability 46, 58-74.   Google Scholar

Schendra, C. (2023), NBM takes over supervision of non-bank lending. Deputy Governor: lending portfolios should become more qualitative. IPN interview, [in:] https://www.bnm.md/en/content/ interview-nbm-takes-over-supervision-non-bank-lending-deputy-governor-lending-portfolios (accessed: 01.07.2024).   Google Scholar

Şenocak, A. (2022), Consumer Law. Turkey, Gide, [in:] https://www.gide.com/sites/default/ files/gide_odsa_clientalert_protection_of_consumers_-_eng_-_may2022_final.pdf (accessed: 09.07.2024).   Google Scholar

Sozer, C. (2021), Turkey Increases Fines for Consumer Law Violations in 2022, [in:] https://www. esin.av.tr/2021/12/17/turkey-increases-fines-for-consumer-law-violations-in-2022/ (accessed: 09.07.2024).   Google Scholar

Stănescu, C. G. (2023), The Enforcement of Consumer Financial Protection in Romania, [in:] Journal of European Consumer and Market Law 12 (3), 102-112, [in:] https://kluwerlawonline. com/journalarticle/Journal+of+European+Consumer+and+Market+Law/12.3/EuCML2023024 (accessed: 17.07.2024)   Google Scholar

Stratulat Albulescu (2024), Government Emergency Ordinance no. 15/2024 on credit services and credit purchasers, [in:] https://saa.ro/en/legal-updates/government-emergency-ordinance-no-15- 2024-on-credit-services-and-credit-purchasers/ (accessed: 12.06.2024)   Google Scholar

UBN – Ukrainian Business News (2024), Experts confirm the recovery of consumer lending in Ukraine, [in:] https://ubn.news/experts-confirm-the-recovery-of-consumer-lending-in-ukraine/ (accessed: 16.07.2024).   Google Scholar

UMW – Warsaw City Office (2024), Kredyt, pożyczka i kredyt konsumencki – czy się różnią?, [in:] https://um.warszawa.pl/waw/konsument/-/kredyt-pozyczka-i-kredyt-konsumencki-czy-sie-roznia- (accessed: 04.07.2024).   Google Scholar

USAID (2018), A rapid review of Moldova’s financial sector. Conditions, constraints, and opportunities, [in:] https://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PA00TGXW.pdf (accessed: 03.06.2024).   Google Scholar

Vasileva, V. N. (2019), Development of consumer lending by non- bank credit companies in Bulgaria, [in:] Economic Archive 1, 65-76. https://dlib.uni-svishtov.bg/bitstream/ handle/10610/4064/5a2d6d047832fc942d5b4ef201f b039a.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y (accessed: 21.07.2024)   Google Scholar

Waliszewski, K. (2022), Wstęp, [in:] Waliszewski, K. (red.), Finanse osobiste. Warszawa, 11-12.   Google Scholar

Waliszewski, K. | Gębski, Ł. (2024), FinTech lenders on the consumer finance market in Central and Eastern Europe, [in:] Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski 15 (1), 81-96.   Google Scholar

Waliszewski, K. | Cichowicz, E. | Gębski, Ł. et al. (2023), The role of the Lendtech sector in the consumer credit market in the context of household financial exclusion, [in:] Oeconomia Copernicana 14 (2), 609-643.   Google Scholar

Waliszewski, K. | Cichowicz, E. | Gębski, Ł. et al. (2024), Digital loans and buy now pay later from LendTech versus bank loans in the era of ‘black swans’: Complementarity in the area of consumer financing, [in:] Equilibrium. Quarterly Journal of Economics and Economic Policy 19 (1), 241-278.   Google Scholar

World Bank (2024), Kazakhstan Financial Sector Assessment Program (FSAP) Technical Note – Consumer Protection and Consumer Lending (English). Washington, D.C.: World Bank Group, [in:] http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/099041124104519180/P1803101da3cce¬0841aed0102126e8e0490 (accessed: 18.06.2024).   Google Scholar

Yuksel, S. | Ozsari, M. (2016, December), Impact of Consumer Loans on Inflation and Current Account Deficit: A Toda Yamamoto Causality Test for Turkey, [in:] World Journal of Applied Economics, WERI-World Economic Research Institute 2 (2), 3-14.   Google Scholar