Dialogic Basis of the Categories of “Openness” and “Tolerance” to the “Other” in Modern Political Discourse – Martin Buber and Gabriel Marcel
Mykhailo Kovalchuk
Ivan Franko National University of Lviv, Faculty of Philosophy, Department of Theory and History of Political Science Universytetska str. 1, 79000 LvivHennadii Shypunov
Ivan Franko National University of Lviv,Faculty of Philosophy, Department of Theory and History of Political Science Universytetska str. 1, 79000 Lvivhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-2961-3516
Abstract
The article analyzes the dialogical nature of the concepts of “tolerance”, “freedom”, “openness”. The interpretation of the dialogical relationship and the appearance of “Other” in it as opposed to “I” through the prism of the concepts of M. Buber and G. Marcel are analyzed. The impact of philosophers of dialogue on the formation of the modern meaning of the concepts “tolerance”, “other”, “openness” is substantiated. The dialogical methodology of interpersonal communications as one of the options for political interaction is considered. The relation “I-You” and the relation “I-It” as principles of construction of mass communication and interpersonal interaction are investigated. The rise in understanding the “Other” in the context of the type of interaction with it is illustrated. The need for mutual openness to enable tolerance is established. Tolerance is seen as the mutual acceptance of two equal freedoms without a dichotomous division into primary and secondary. On the example of dialogic concepts of M. Buber and G. Marcel, the types of dialogical interaction with the “Other” and the possible interpretation of the “Other”, including its typology, are demonstrated. The influence of dialogic interpretation of intersubjective connection on the formation of modern European values is determined.
Keywords:
dyskurs polityczny, tolerancja, wolność, otwartość, „Inny”, dialog, stosunek, relacja „Ja-Ty”, przynależnośćReferences
Buber Martin, 1970, I and Thou. Charles Scribner’s Sons, New York. Google Scholar
Buber Martin,1995, Dialogue. Respublika, Moscow. Google Scholar
Burkhanov Alexander, 2011, Existential of Hope in Theistic Philosophy of Gabriel Mar cel, Molodoi Uchenyi, No. 5, T. 1, p. 240–245. Google Scholar
Habermas Jürgen, 2015, A Philosophy of Dialogue, in: Mendes-Flohr P. ed., Dialogue as a Trans-disciplinary Concept, Berlin, München, Boston: De Gruyter, p. 7–20, https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110402223-002.
Crossref
Google Scholar
Jasiński Karol, 2012, God as “Eternal Thou”. Martin Buber’s Dialogical Philosophy of God, Idea. Studia Nad Strukturą i Rozwojem Pojęć Filozoficznych, Issue 24, p. 147–174.
Crossref
Google Scholar
Klochovskyi Jan Andrzej, 2013, Philosophy of Dialogue, Kyiv: Dukh i Litera. Google Scholar
Kovalchuk Mykhailo, 2017, The Dialogue of Martin Buber and the Place of the “Other” in It, Scientific Notes of Ostrozka Academy, National University (“Philosophy” Series), Ostrog: Publishing House of Ostrozka Academy, National University, 2017, Issue 20, p.18–22. Google Scholar
Kovalchuk Yulia, 2015, Love as a Revelation Between “I” and “You” in the Philosophy of Dialogue, Scientific Notes of Ostrozka Academy, National University (“Philosophy” Series), Ostrog: Publishing House of Ostrozka Academy, National University, Issue 17, p.107–111. Google Scholar
Malakhov Victor, 2002, Faith. Fidelity. Tolerance, Ontology of Dialogue: Metaphysical and Religious Experience, St. Petersburg: FKITS “Eidos”, 2002, p. 103–111. Google Scholar
Marcel Gabriel, 1949, Being and Having. Dacre Press, Westminster. Google Scholar
Marcel Gabriel, 1967, Presence and Immortality, Duquesne University Press, Pitts burgh. Google Scholar
Marcel Gabriel, 1973, Tragic Wisdom and Beyond, Northwestern University Press, Evanston. Google Scholar
Omelchenko Iryna, 2015, Intercourse as Communication, Interaction and Dialogue with the Other: a Subjective Approach, Kyiv, Issue 28, p. 375–384. Google Scholar
Poliarush Borys, 2017, Dialogic Understanding of Openness, Bulletin of Lviv Universi ty. Philosophy and Politology Series, Lviv, Issue 14, p. 74–79. Google Scholar
Shypunov Hennadii, 2012, Tolerance as a Factor in the Democratization of Post-Authoritarian Societies, Tolerance as a Social and Cultural Phenomenon: Ideological and Methodological Aspect: Collective Monograph, Lviv: Ivan Franko National Uni versity of Lviv, p. 136–153. Google Scholar
Vizgin Victor, 2013, Gabriel Marcel. About Courage in Metaphysics, Saint-Petersburg: Nauka. Google Scholar
Ziborova Daria, 2008, Hour and Anthropology: Memory, Dialogue, Other, Multiversum. Philosophical Almanac: Collection of Scientific Papers, Kyiv, Edition 73, p. 78–94. Google Scholar
Ivan Franko National University of Lviv, Faculty of Philosophy, Department of Theory and History of Political Science Universytetska str. 1, 79000 Lviv
Ivan Franko National University of Lviv,Faculty of Philosophy, Department of Theory and History of Political Science Universytetska str. 1, 79000 Lviv
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2961-3516
