The Method of Rhetoric as Seen by John Italos
Magdalena Jaworska
The Jacob of Paradies University, Gorzów WielkopolskiMichał Klementowicz
John Paul II Catholic University of LublinAbstract
John Italos (1025–1085), a prominent Byzantine philosopher, was not regarded by his contemporaries as a great rhetorician. However, even from an early age, he did make a name for himself as a dialectician and polemicist. For this reason, his treatise, Methodos Rhetorikê garnered considerable attention. The present article seeks to demonstrate that this important work possesses some key intellectual elements relevant to rhetoric. Besides the title of the work, Italos’ references to the Aristotelian view of the art of speech demonstrates such relevance. In particular, we highlight the use of syllogisms and the notion of the distinctiveness of rhetoric from controversy and dialectic. At the same time, the eleventh century scholar’s proposal includes elements of rhetoric that depart from the Stagirites’ views, such as ways of understanding the ethos of the speaker, certain principles related to argumentation, and the relationship between rhetoric and ethics. Our analysis of Italos’ work makes it possible to appreciate the reception of classical rhetorical content in the Eastern
Roman Empire in 11th century.
Keywords:
Aristotle, Byzantium, John Italos, rhetoricReferences
Arystoteles, Retoryka, Poetyka, PWN, Warszawa 1988. Google Scholar
Arystoteles, Topiki O dowodach sofistycznych, PWN, Warszawa 1978. Google Scholar
Arystoteles, Etyka nikomachejska, PWN, Warszawa 1981. Google Scholar
Browning Robert, 1975, Enlightenment and Repression in Byzantium in the Eleventh and Twelfth Centuries, Past & Present, nr. 66-69, s. 3-23.
Crossref
Google Scholar
Conley Thomas, 1998, The Alleged Synopsis of Aristotle’s Rhetoric by John Italos and its Place in the Byzantine Reception of Aristotle w: Gilbert Dahan, Irène Rosier-Catach (ed.), La Rhétorique d’Aristote: Traditions et Commentaires de l’Antiquité au XVIIᵉ Siècle, Paris, s. 49-64.
Crossref
Google Scholar
Conley Thomas, 1994, Notes on the Byzantine Reception of the Peripatetic Tradition in Rhetoric w: William Fortenbaugh, David Mirhady (ed.), Peripatetic Rhetoric after Aristotle, Transaction Publishers, New Brunswick, s. 217-241. Google Scholar
Conley Thomas, 2004, John Italos’ Methodos Rhetorikê: Text and Commentary, Greek, Roman, and Byzantine Studies, nr 44, s. 411-437. Google Scholar
Conley Thomas, 1990, Aristotle’s Rhetoric in Byzantium, Rhetorica, vol. VIII, nr. 1, s. 29-44.
Crossref
Google Scholar
Iannis Itali Opera, 1966, Кечакмадзе Иосиф Ильич (red.), Издательство Мецниереба, Tbilisi. Google Scholar
Italos Ioannes, 1956, Quaestiones Quodlibetales, Périclès-Pierre Joannou (red.), Buch-Kunstverlag Ettal, Ettal. Google Scholar
Jurewicz Oktawiusz, 1984, Historia literatury bizantyjskiej, Wydawnictwo Ossolineum, Wrocław. Google Scholar
Kennedy George Alexander, 1983, Greek Rhetoric under Christian Emperors, Princeton University Press, Princeton. Google Scholar
Komnena Anna, 2005 Aleksjada, t. 1, Wydawnictwo Ossolineum we współpracy z De Agostini, Wrocław. Google Scholar
Romano Rolland, 1992, Un opuscolo inedito di Giovanni Italo, Bollettino dei Classici, fasc. XIII, s. 14-24. Google Scholar
Stephanou Pelopidas Etienne, 1949, Jean Italos philosophe et humaniste, Orientalia Christiana Analecta 134, Roma. Google Scholar
The Jacob of Paradies University, Gorzów Wielkopolski
John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin
