Osiemnastowieczna dyskusja na temat tożsamości osobowej

Andrzej Stoiński

doi:10.31648/hip.392

Published: 2018-08-181

No. 22 (2016)

teenth-Century Dispute about Personal Identity

Andrzej Stoiński

Humanities and Natural Sciences

Section: Articles

https://doi.org/10.31648/hip.392

Abstract

The paper describes some aspects of eighteenth-century philosophical disputes. The controversies were inspired by Lockean theory about a person and personal identity. The discussion was referred to the substantial nature of personal identity and to the role of consciousness in it. In the first case, Leibniz, Butler and Reid argued for the substantial nature of human identity while, Locke avoided taking a position. The second issue, in large part, was linked to the previous, and it indicates, among other things, similar spreading of opinions. Locke recognized consciousness as an essential criterion of personal identity, but Leibniz, Butler and Reid opposed to that position.

Keywords:

Locke, metaphysics of a person, personal identity, person

Most read articles by the same author(s)

Andrzej Stoiński, Selected Topics of Criticism of Utilitarianism , Humanities and Natural Sciences: No. 20 (2014)
Andrzej Stoiński, Freedom „from " and Freedom „to" - Reciprocal Relations , Humanities and Natural Sciences: No. 19 (2013)
Andrzej Stoiński, Some Remarks on Sources of Critique of Neoliberalism , Humanities and Natural Sciences: No. 17 (2011)
Andrzej Stoiński, The state and the justice , Humanities and Natural Sciences: No. 18 (2012)
Andrzej Stoiński, Funeral Rite and Attitude in the Face of Death , Humanities and Natural Sciences: No. 7 (2001)
Andrzej Stoiński, Albert Einstein – filozof , Humanities and Natural Sciences: No. 7 (2001)
Andrzej Stoiński, Ekologia krytyczna Andrzeja Papuzińskiego , Humanities and Natural Sciences: No. 6 (2000)
Andrzej Stoiński, From the object of justice to subjective rights. On transformation of the meaning of rights and some consequences of it , Humanities and Natural Sciences: No. 28 (2022)

Download files

PDF (Język Polski)

Citation rules

Stoiński, A. (2018). teenth-Century Dispute about Personal Identity. Humanities and Natural Sciences, (22), 253–267. https://doi.org/10.31648/hip.392

Cited by / Share

Licence

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

References

Ayer A.J., The Concept o f a Person, St. Martin’s, New York 1963. Boecjusz, O pociechach filozofii. Traktaty teologiczne, tłum. T. Jachimowski, De Agostini, Warszawa 2003.

Butler J., Analogy o f Religion, Harper & Brothers, New York 1860.

Butler J., O f Personal Identity, (w:) J. Perry (red.), Personal Identity, University of California, Berkeley 1975.

Frankfurt H.G., Wolność i pojęcie osoby, (w:) Filozofia moralności. Postanowienie i odpowiedzialność moralna, wybór J. Hołówka, SPACJA. Warszawa 1997.

Gutowski P., O trzech elementach filozofii Thomasa Reida, „Roczniki Filozoficzne”, t. LVIII, nr 1, s. 71-93.

Gutowski P., Szubka T. (red.), Filozofia brytyjska u schyłku X X wieku, Towarzystwo Naukowe KUL, Lublin 1998.

Hempoliński M., Filozofia współczesna, PWN, Warszawa 1989.

Leibniz G. W., Metaphysical Disputation on the Principle o f an Individual, tłum. z łaciny na angielski P. V. Spade, Oklahoma State University, Stillwater 1982.

Leibniz G. W., Nowe rozważania dotyczące rozumu ludzkiego, tłum. I. Dąbska, PWN, Warszawa 1955.

Leibniz G. W., Zasady filozofii czyli monadologia, [w:] Wyznanie wiary filozofa, tłum. S. Cichowicz, PWN, Warszawa 1969.

Locke J., Rozważania dotyczące rozumu ludzkiego, tłum. B. Gawecki, PWN, Warszawa 1955.

Lodge P., Stoneham T. (red.), Locke and Leibniz on Substance, Routledge, New York 2015.

Martin R., Barresi J. (red.), Personal Identity, Blackwell, Oxford 2002. Noonan H. W., Personal Identity, Routledge, London 1989. Oksenberg Rorty A. (red.), The Identities o f Persons, University of California Press, Berkeley 1976.

Parfit D., Reasons and Person, Oxford University Press, Oxford 1986.

Perry J., A Dialog on Personal Identity and Immortality, Indianapolis, Hackett 1978.

Reid T., Essays on the Intellectual Powers o f Man, [w:] idem. The Works o f Thomas Reid, Elibron Classics, Edinburgh 1872, [online] (dostęp: 6.09.2015).

Reid T., O f Identity, (w:) Perry J. (red.), Personal Identity, University of California, Berkeley 1975.

Shoemaker S., Self-knowledge and Self-identity, Ithaca, New York 1963.

Shoemaker S., Swinburne R., Personal Identity, Blackwell, Oxford 1984.

Stoiński A., Kryteria tożsamości osobowej, „Szkice Humanistyczne” 2002, t. II, nr 1/2, s. 147-159.

Strawson P. F., Indywidua. Próba metafizyki opisowej, tłum. B. Chwedeńczuk, PAX, Warszawa 1980.

Vesey G., Personal Identity, Macmillan, London 1974.

Wiggins D., Identity and Spatio-Temporal Continuity, Blackwell, Oxford 1967.

Williams B., The Self and the Future, [w:] Perry J. (red.), Personal Identity, University of California Press, Berkeley 1975.

Witkowski L., O problemie tożsamości osobowej w filozofii: część I: J. Locke, G. W. Leibniz, „Acta Universitatis Nicolai Copernici, Filozofia 11” 1990, (197), s. 99-113.

Ziemiński I., Moralność i religia. Poglądy filozoficzne Josepha Butlera, PWN, Warszawa 2002. Google Scholar