Finansowanie zielonych technologii przez pomoc państwa – miedzy prawem do czystego środowiska a ekonomicznym pragmatyzmem

Jakub Kociubiński

Uniwersytet Wrocławski
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4391-7439


Abstract

The need to counteract the progressing degradation of the natural environment has become one of the European Union’s top priorities. Efforts in this direction are carried out through a set of policies and legislative initiatives under the common label Green Deal. The stated objective is to eliminate emissions caused by the European economy and reduce its dependence on fossil fuels. This requires employing State aid since many necessary green technologies are immature and expensive. This paper presents the relationship between the Treaty’s imperative of promoting a clean environment and the objective of maintaining a competitive European economy. The analysis will seek to verify the hypothesis that the existing standard of assessment of the effect on trade and competition used in State aid cases can potentially lead to abuses whereby Member States can create an unfair advantage to selective undertakings by using environmental justification as carte blanche for funding. This paper presents the relationship between the Treaty’s imperative of promoting a clean environment and the objective of maintaining a competitive European economy. The analysis will seek to verify the hypothesis that the existing standard of assessment of the effect on trade and competition used in State aid cases can potentially lead to abuses whereby Member States can create an unfair advantage to selective undertakings by using environmental justification as carte blanche for funding.

 

 


Keywords:

European Union law, state aid, Green Deal, green technologies, competition


Ahlborn C., Berg C., Can State aid control learn from antitrust? The need for a greater role for competition analysis under the State aid rules [in:] The Law of State Aid in the European Union, A. Biondi, P. Eeckhout, & J. Flynn (eds), Oxford University Press, Oxford 2004   Google Scholar

Avgerinopoulou D., Science-Based Lawmaking How to Effectively Integrate Science in International Environmental Law, Springer, Cham 2019   Google Scholar

Avilés L.A., Sustainable development and the legal protection of the environment in Europe, “Sustainable Development Law & Policy” 2012, no 3   Google Scholar

Binet Ch., L’Europe et son Green Deal -Quel avenir pour le climat? “Journal de droit européen 2020”, no 5   Google Scholar

Cnossen S., Dictus G., Big on big, small on small: Never ending promise? Critical assessment of the Commission decision practice with regard to the effect on trade criterion, “European State Aid Law Quarterly” 2021, no 20   Google Scholar

Damjanovic D., The EU market rules as social market rules: Why the EU can be a social market economy, “Common Market Law Review” 2013, no 50   Google Scholar

de Cecco F., State Aid and the European Economic Constitution, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham 2012   Google Scholar

Eskridge W., Ferejohn J., Structuring Lawmaking to Reduce Cognitive Bias: A Critical View, “Cornell Law Reviev” 2002   Google Scholar

Friederiszick H.W., Roller L-H., Verouden V., European State Aid Control: An Economic Framework [in:] Handbook of Antitrust Economics, P. Buccirossi (ed), The MIT Press, Cambridge 2008   Google Scholar

Gerber D., Law and Competition in Twentieth Century Europe. Protecting Prometheus, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2001   Google Scholar

Gràcia N., Lunneryd I, Papaefthymiou A., The race towards a more sustainable future: is current State aid policy fit for purpose? “Competition Law & Policy Debate” 2023, no 8   Google Scholar

Heimler A., Jenny F., The limitations of European Union control of State aid, “Oxford Review of Economic Policy” 2012, no 28   Google Scholar

Humphreys M., Sustainable Development in the European Union: A General Principle, Routledge, Abigdon 2018   Google Scholar

Jorges F., Rödl S., „Social Market Economy” as Europe’s Social Model?, “EUI Working Paper LAW” 2004, no. 8   Google Scholar

Kassim H., Lyons B., The New Political Economy of EU State Aid Policy, “Journal of Industry, Competition and Trade” 2013, no. 13   Google Scholar

Kellerbauer M., Klamert M., Tomkin J. (eds), The EU Treaties and the Charter of Fundamental Rights: A Commentary, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2019   Google Scholar

Krämer L., EU Environmental Law, Bloomsbury, London 2016   Google Scholar

Langlet D., Mahmoudi S., EU Environmental Law and Policy, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2016   Google Scholar

Larik J., From speciality to a constitutional sense of purpose: on the changing role of the objectives of the European Union, “International and Comparative Law Quarterly” 2014, no 63   Google Scholar

Parret L., The multiple personalities of EU competition law: time for a comprehensive debate on its objectives [in:] The Goals of Competition Law, D. Zimmer (ed), Edward Elgar, Cheltenham 2012   Google Scholar

Pianta M., Lucchese M., Rethinking the European Green Deal: An Industrial Policy for a Just Transition in Europe, “Review of Radical Political Economics” 2020, no 54   Google Scholar

Rawls J., Theory of Justice, Belknap Press, Cambridge 1971   Google Scholar

Riley A., The EU Reform Treaty and the Competition Protocol: Undermining EC Competition Law, “European Competition Law Review” 2008, no. 12   Google Scholar

Rodrigues R., Pietzcker R., Fragkos P., Price J., McDowall W., Siskos P., Fotiou T., Luderer G., Capros P., Narrative-driven alternative roads to achieve mid-century CO2 net neutrality in Europe, “Energy” 2022, no 239(A)   Google Scholar

Roosevelt K., Certainty vs. Flexibility in the Conflict of Laws, “Public Law and Legal Theory Research Paper” 2018   Google Scholar

Sauter W., Coherence in EU Competition Law, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2016   Google Scholar

Scharpf F., The asymmetry of European integration, or why the EU cannot be a ‘social market economy’, “Socio-Economic Review” 2010, no 8   Google Scholar

Scheppele K., Kochenov D., Grabowska-Moroz B., EU Values Are Law, after All: Enforcing EU Values through Systemic Infringement Actions by the European Commission and the Member States of the European Union, “Yearbook of European Law” 2020, no 39   Google Scholar

Sikora A., European Green Deal – legal and financial challenges of the climate change, “ERA Forum” 2021, no 21   Google Scholar

Ştefan O., Soft Law in Court: Competition Law, State Aid, and the Court of Justice of the European Union, Kluwer, Den Haag 2013   Google Scholar

Temple Lang J., EU State aid rules – the need for substantive reform, “European State Aid Law Quarterly” 2014, no. 13   Google Scholar

Werner P., Verouden V. (eds), EU State Aid Control: law and Economics, Wolters Kluwer, Alphen aan den Rijn 2016   Google Scholar


Published
2024-12-17

Cited by

Kociubiński, J. (2024). Finansowanie zielonych technologii przez pomoc państwa – miedzy prawem do czystego środowiska a ekonomicznym pragmatyzmem. Studia Prawnoustrojowe, (66). https://doi.org/10.31648/sp.10306

Jakub Kociubiński 
Uniwersytet Wrocławski
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4391-7439