Dispute about a poem On the Independence of Ukraine by Joseph Brodsky. Part 1
Piotr Fast
University of Silesia in KatowiceAbstract
The article presents several critical and journalistic statements devoted to Joseph Brodsky’s poem On the Independence of Ukraine, written several months after the country gained statehood and political independence from Russia. Some of their authors (e.g. Oksana Zabuzhko) accuse the poet of a chauvinist and imperial approach to Ukrainian sovereignty, and treat it as part of the cultural world of Russia. Friends and admirers of Brodsky’s work (e.g. Adam Zagajewski, Aleksander Fiut) react to this text differently. They seek justification for the poet’s attitude, although they often express surprise and lack of understanding of why he wrote a poem with such an expression. They have also appeared works which, using an objectified conceptual apparatus (e.g. Yevgeny Breydo), try to defend the poet against the accusations made by critics.
The article is the first part of the study dealing with this issue; the second will be devoted to searching for the intellectual and psychological premises that led to its creation.
Keywords:
Joseph Brodsky, poem On the Independence of Ukraine, critical opinions, imperial approach, colonial way of thinkingReferences
A vy uchilis’… (2014), „A vy uchilis’ etomu?” Stennograma suda nad Iosifom Brodskim, [„А вы учились этому?” Стенограмма суда над Иосифом Бродским,] [in:] https://tvrain.tv/teleshow/ archive/a_vy_uchilis_etomu_stenogramma_suda_nad_iosifom_brodskim-378906/ (accessed: 15.02.2025). Google Scholar
Bertelsen, O. (2015), Joseph Brodsky’s Imperial Consciousness, [in:] Scripta Historica 21, 263-289. Google Scholar
Brodsky, J. (1983), A Martial law carrol. The New York Review 17.03, [in:] https://www.nybooks. com/articles/1983/03/17/a-martial-law-carol/ (accessed: 15.02.2025). Google Scholar
Brodsky, J. (1992а), Bosnia Tune, [in:] https://www.spiritofbosnia.org/volume-2-no-3-2007-july/ bosnia-tune-1992/ (accessed: 15.02.2025). Google Scholar
Brodski, I. (1992b), Ne nezavisimost’ Ukrainy, [Бродский, И.] (1992b), На независимость Украины,] [in:] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=grFRNnPePJw/ (accessed: 15.02.2025). Google Scholar
Brejdo, E. (2023), Kommentarii k stikham Brodskogo „Na nezavisimost’ Ukrainy”, [in:] Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie 5, [Брейдо, E. (2023), Комментарий к стихам Бродского „На незави-симость Украины”, [in:] Новое литературное обозрение 5,] [in:] https://magazines.gorky. media/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/15.-brejdo.pdf (accessed: 15.02.2025). Google Scholar
Fiut, A. (2023), Wyglądy i wglądy. Kraków. Google Scholar
Grudzińska-Gros, I. (2009), Czesław Miłosz and Joseph Brodsky. Fellowships of poets. New Haven | London. Google Scholar
Grudzińska-Gros, I. (2012), Horror, terror i klasycy. Sejny. Google Scholar
Grudzińska-Gros, I. (2007), Miłosz i Brodski. Pole magnetyczne. Kraków. Google Scholar
Impierskiy tekst… (2023), Imperskiy tekst v russkoi poezii. Anketa, [in:] Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie 5, [Имперский текст в русской поэзии. Анкета, [in:] Новое литературное обозрение 5,] [in:] https://magazines.gorky.media/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/16.-imperskij-tekst-v-russkoj-poezii.pdf (accessed: 15.02.2025). Google Scholar
Jangfeldt, B. (2012), Yazyk est bog. Zametki ob Iosife Brodskom. Transl. from Swedish Yangfeldt, B. Moskva. [Янгфельдт, Б. (2012), Язык есть Бог. Заметки об Иосифе Бродском. Пер. со швед. Янгфельдта, Б. Москва]. Google Scholar
Komorowski, A. (2023), „Bez tom wieche z pawich piór”. Twórczość 2, [w:] https://tworczosc.com. pl/artykul/bez-tom-wieche-z-pawich-pior/ (accessed: 15.02.2025). Google Scholar
Margolis, J. (2022), Esli vypalo v imperii rodit’sya. Brodskii i kolonializm russkoy kultury, [Марголис, E. (2022) Если выпало в имерии родиться. Бродский и колониализм русской культуры/,] [in:] https://novayagazeta.eu/articles/2022/07/09/esli-vypalo-v-imperii-roditsia (accessed: 15.02.2025)199 Google Scholar
Polak-Pałkiewicz, E. (b.d.), Ukraina – gdzie to jest?, [w:] http://ewapolak-palkiewicz.pl/ukraina-gdzie-to-jest/ (accessed: 15.02.2025). Google Scholar
Skotnicka, A. (2025), Pisarze rosyjscy wobec autokolonialności, [w:] Przegląd Rusycystyczny 1, 294-310. Google Scholar
Szaruga, L. (2016), Przetwarzanie międzymorza. Zarys problematyki. Kraków | Warszawa. Google Scholar
Venclova, T. (2009), Foreword, [in:] Grudzińska-Gross, I. (2009), Czesław Miłosz and Joseph Brodsky. Fellowships of poets. New Haven | London. Google Scholar
Zagajewski, A. (2020), O Josifie Brodskim, chaotycznie, [w:] Zeszyty Literackie 8, [w:] https:// zeszytyliterackie.pl/adam-zagajewski-o-josifie-brodskim-chaotycznie/ (accessed: 15.02.2025). Google Scholar
Zabużko, O. (1998), Proshchannya z іmperієyu: kіl’ka shtrikhіv do odnogo portreta, [in:] Dukh i litera 3-4. [Забужко, О. (1998), Прощання з імперією: кілька штрихів до одного портрета, [in:] Дух і літера 3-4.] Google Scholar
Zabużko, O. (2001), Planeta Piołun [esej Szkic do pewnego portretu. Transl. Majewska, J.]. Warszawa. Google Scholar
Zygar, M. (2023), Voyna i nakazanye. Kak Rossiya unichtozhala Ukrainu. Riga. [Зыгарь, М. (2023), Война и наказание. Как Россия уничтожала Украину. Riga.] Google Scholar
University of Silesia in Katowice
Most read articles by the same author(s)
- Piotr Fast, Do we need a new history of 20th Century Russian literature? , Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski: Vol. 14 No. 2 (2023): East European Review
- Piotr Fast, Brodsky and Rubtsov – the identity contexts of two poems , Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski: Vol. 12 No. 2 (2021): East European Review
- Piotr Fast, Dispute about a poem On the Independence of Ukraine by Joseph Brodsky. Part 2 , Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski: Vol. 17 No. 1 (2026): East European Review
Similar Articles
- Stanisław Goźdź-Roszkowski, Julia Mazurkiewicz-Sułkowska, The status of generic structure in expert opinions. Insights from a comparative analysis of American, Russian and Bulgarian documents , Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski: Vol. 13 No. 2 (2022): East European Review
- Piotr Fast, Dispute about a poem On the Independence of Ukraine by Joseph Brodsky. Part 2 , Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski: Vol. 17 No. 1 (2026): East European Review
- Mirosława Wielopolska-Szymura, Content and programs dedicated to the Ukrainian population in the activities of the Polish Radio External Service and the Polish Radio for Ukraine , Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski: Vol. 16 No. 2 (2025): East European Review
- Anna Pavlova, Structural-field approach to syntactic phraseology of Russian. Part I , Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski: Vol. 13 No. 2 (2022): East European Review
- Yuliana Palagnyuk, Threat, savior, or victim? How Ukrainian online news media represent labor migrants during Russia’s aggression against Ukraine , Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski: Vol. 16 No. 2 (2025): East European Review
- Bara Ndiaye, Russian-African relations in the light of the war in Ukraine , Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski: Vol. 14 No. 1 (2023): East European Review
- Ihor Kozak, Iryna Kozak-Balaniuk, Assessment of and compensation for environmental damage from Russian aggression in Ukraine – An ecosystem approach and legal instruments , Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski: Vol. 16 No. 2 (2025): East European Review
- Paweł Pietnoczka, Constitutional process in Ukraine in 2014-2016 , Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski: Vol. 8 No. 2 (2017): East European Review
- Łukasz Jureńczyk, NATO enlargement to the East and the war in Ukraine from the American perspective , Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski: Vol. 15 No. 1 (2024): East European Review
- Vladimir Shaidurov, The Siberian Polonia in the second half of the 19th - early 20th century in the Polish historiography , Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski: Vol. 8 No. 1 (2017): East European Review
You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.
