Controversies in Polish-Russian Relations over the Approach to Ukraine and Georgia

Łukasz Jureńczyk

Uniwersytet Kazimierza Wielkiego w Bydgoszczy


Abstract

The subject of the paper are the United Kingdom’s actions against Russia's attempts to maintain its zones of influence, based on the example of the Ukrainian crisis. The introduction consists of a synthetic outline of the geopolitical rivalry between Russia and Great Britain. The next section discusses the attitude of the United Kingdom towards Russia’s attempts to maintain its zones of influence in the 21st century. The main section of the paper focuses on the United Kingdom’s actions against Russia’s military policy in Ukraine. The main thesis of the paper assumes that during the Ukrainian crisis, the UK has taken the most far-reaching measures so far to oppose Russia’s attempts to maintain zones of influence. The consequence of this is a significant deterioration in Russian-British relations due to the Ukrainian crisis. The leading paradigm is structural realism. The method of text source analysis was used in the paper.


Keywords:

Russian zones of influence, politics of the United Kingdom, Ukrainian crisis, Russia-United Kingdom relations, geopolitics


AALTO, P. (2009), EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVES FOR MANAGING DEPENDENCE. IN: PEROVIC, J./ORTTUNG, R. W./WENGER, A. (EDS.), RUSSIAN ENERGY POWER AND FOREIGN RELATIONS. IMPLICATIONS FOR CONFLICT AND COOPERATION. LON-DON/NEW YORK, 157-180.   Google Scholar

ARAKELYAN, L. A. (2014). THE SOVIET UNION IS DEAD: LONG LIVE THE EURASIAN UNION! IN: KANET, R. E./PIET R. (EDS.), SHIFTING PRIORITIES IN RUSSIA’S FOREIGN AND SECURITY POLICY. LONDON/NEW YORK, 141-162.   Google Scholar

BLACK, J. L. (2015). THE RUSSIAN PRESIDENCY OF DMITRY MEDVEDEV, 2008-2012. THE NEXT STEP FORWARD OR MERELY A TIME OUT? LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

CALLAGHAN, J. (2007), THE LABOUR PARTY AND FOREIGN POLICY. A HISTORY. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

CAWKWELL, T. W. (2016), UK COMMUNICATION STRATEGIES FOR AFGHANISTAN, 2001–2014. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

CHENOY, A. M./KUMAR, R. (2017), RE-EMERGING RUSSIA. STRUCTURES, INSTITUTIONS AND PROCESSES. SINGAPORE.
Crossref   Google Scholar

CICHOS, K. (2018), „WARTOŚCI” CZY BEZPIECZEŃSTWO? POLITYKA SĄSIEDZKA UE (NA PRZYKŁADZIE RELACJI Z UKRAINĄ). IN: PRZEGLĄD WSCHODNIOEUROPEJSKI. IX/1, 119-128.
Crossref   Google Scholar

CLOSSON, S. (2009), RUSSIA’S KEY CUSTOMER: EUROPE. IN: PEROVIC, J./ORTTUNG, R. W./WENGER, A. (EDS.), RUSSIAN ENERGY POWER AND FOREIGN RELATIONS. IMPLICATIONS FOR CONFLICT AND COOPERATION. LONDON/NEW YORK, 89-108.   Google Scholar

CODNER, M. (2016), AN INSTRUMENT OF HONOUR? BRITAIN’S MILITARY STRATEGY AND THE IMPACT OF NEW TECHNOLO-GIES. IN: BROWN, D. (ED.), THE DEVELOPMENT OF BRITISH DEFENCE POLICY. BLAIR, BROWN AND BEYOND. LON-DON/NEW YORK, 189-214.   Google Scholar

COUGHLIN, C. (2018), RUSSIA POSES GREATER THREAT TO BRITAIN THAN ISIL, SAYS NEW ARMY CHIEF. THE TELEGRAPH. 23 NOVEMBER. IN: HTTPS://WWW.TELEGRAPH.CO.UK/NEWS/2018/11/23/RUSSIA-POSES-GREATER-THREAT-BRITAIN-ISIL-SAYS-NEW-ARMY-CHIEF/ [ACCESS: 20 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

DOBSON, A. P. (1995), ANGLO-AMERICAN RELATIONS IN THE TWENTIETH CENTURY. OF FRIENDSHIP, CONFLICT AND THE RISE AND DECLINE OF SUPERPOWERS. LONDON/NEW YORK.   Google Scholar

DONALDSON, R. H./NOGEE, J. L./NADKARNI, V. (2015), THE FOREIGN POLICY OF RUSSIA. CHANGING SYSTEMS, ENDUR-ING INTERESTS. FIFTH EDITION. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

DOVER, R. (2016), EUROPEANIZATION OF BRITISH DEFENCE POLICY. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

ENGELBREKT, K./VASSILEV, I. (2010), EUROPEAN ENERGY POLICY MEETS RUSSIAN BILATERALISM: THE CASE OF SOUTH-EASTERN EUROPE. IN: ENGELBREKT, K./NYGREN, B. (EDS), RUSSIA AND EUROPE. BUILDING BRIDGES, DIGGING TRENCHES. LONDON/NEW YORK, 187-206.
Crossref   Google Scholar

FEDOROV, Y. E. (2010), THE RETURN OF HISTORY: HARD SECURITY ISSUES IN THE RUSSIA–EUROPE RELATIONSHIP. IN: ENGEL-BREKT, K./NYGREN, B. (EDS), RUSSIA AND EUROPE. BUILDING BRIDGES, DIGGING TRENCHES. LONDON/NEW YORK, 103-131.
Crossref   Google Scholar

GENERAL ASSEMBLY UN (2014), RESOLUTION ADOPTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY ON 27 MARCH 2014. 68/262. TERRITORIAL INTEGRITY OF UKRAINE. NEW YORK. 27 MARCH. IN: HTTPS://WWW.UN.ORG/EN/GA/SEARCH/VIEW_DOC.ASP?SYMBOL=A/RES/68/262 [ACCESS: 12 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

GOODE, J. P. (2011), THE DECLINE OF REGIONALISM IN PUTIN’S RUSSIA. BOUNDARY ISSUES. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

GOWLAND, D. (2017), BRITAIN AND THE EUROPEAN UNION. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

HER MAJESTY GOVERNMENT (2015), NATIONAL SECURITY STRATEGY AND STRATEGIC DEFENCE AND SECURITY REVIEW 2015. A SECURE AND PROSPEROUS UNITED KINGDOM. LONDON. IN: HTTPS://ASSETS.PUBLISHING.SERVICE.GOV.UK/GOVERNMENT/UPLOADS/SYSTEM/UPLOADS/ATTACHMENT_DATA/FILE/478933/52309_CM_9161_NSS_SD_REVIEW_WEB_ONLY.PDF [ACCESS: 12 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

HODGE, C. (2006), BRITAIN AND THE BALKANS. 1991 UNTIL THE PRESENT. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

HOUSE OF LORDS (2015), EUROPEAN UNION COMMITTEE, 6TH REPORT OF SESSION 2014–15. THE EU AND RUSSIA: BEFORE AND BEYOND THE CRISIS IN UKRAINE. 20 FEBRUARY. IN: HTTPS://PUBLICATIONS.PARLIAMENT.UK/PA/LD201415/LDSELECT/LDEUCOM/115/115.PDF [ACCESS: 16 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

KMIECIK, P. (2013), REALIZM STRUKTURALNY OFENSYWNY, DEFENSYWNY I ZALEŻNY. IN: HTTP://WWW.NOWASTRATEGIA.ORG.PL/REALIZM/ [ACCESS: 10 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

KOCHO-WILLIAMS, A. (2013), RUSSIA’S INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS IN THE TWENTIETH CENTURY. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

KOVAL, N. (2018), UNITED KINGDOM. IN: MAKSAK, H./TURCSÁNYI, R. Q./VOROTNYUK, M. (EDS.), UNDERSTANDING STRA-TEGIC ADAPTATIONS: SECURITY STRATEGIES AND POLICIES AFTER 2014. BRATISLAVA / KYIV.   Google Scholar

KRAMER, A. E. (2018), RUSSIA EXPELS 23 BRITISH DIPLOMATS, ESCALETING ROW OVER EX-SPY’S POISONING. THE NEW YORK TIMES. 17 MARCH. IN: HTTPS://WWW.NYTIMES.COM/2018/03/17/WORLD/EUROPE/RUSSIA-EXPEL-BRITAIN-DIPLOMATS.HTML [ACCESS: 20 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

LANTEIGNE, M. (2016), CHINESE FOREIGN POLICY. AN INTRODUCTION. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

LEICHTOWA, M. (2016), MISUNDERSTANDING RUSSIA. RUSSIAN FOREIGN POLICY AND THE WEST. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

LOBELL, S. E. (2017), STRUCTURAL REALISM/OFFENSIVE AND DEFENSIVE REALISM. IN: HTTPS://OXFORDRE.COM/INTERNATIONALSTUDIES/VIEW/10.1093/ACREFORE/9780190846626.001.0001/ACREFORE-9780190846626-E-304 [ACCESS: 10 VIII 2019].
Crossref   Google Scholar

LUHN, A. (2018), PUTIN CALLS FOR BETTER UK-RUSSIA RELATIONS AT MASSIVE ANNUAL PRESS CONFERENCE. THE TELEGRAPH. 20 DECEMBER. IN: HTTPS://WWW.TELEGRAPH.CO.UK/NEWS/2018/12/20/PUTIN-HOLDS-MARATHON-ANNUAL-PRESS-CONFERENCE-TURBULENT-YEAR/ [ACCESS: 20 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

MEMORANDUM ON SECURITY ASSURANCES IN CONNECTION WITH UKRAINE'S ACCESSION TO THE TREATY ON THE NON-PROLIFERATION OF NUCLEAR WEAPONS (1994), 5 DECEMBER. IN: HTTPS://TREATIES.UN.ORG/DOC/PUBLICATION/UNTS/NO%20VOLUME/52241/PART/I-52241-0800000280401FBB.PDF [ACCESS: 12 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

MILCZANOWSKI, M. (2014), ZACHÓD WOBEC KRYZYSU POLITYCZNEGO NA UKRAINIE (2013-2014). IN: BEZPIECZEŃST-WO: TEORIA I PRAKTYKA. 8/3, 25-38.   Google Scholar

MORRIS, N./USBORNE, D. (2014), UKRAINE CRISIS: THIS IS EUROPE’S BIGGEST CRISIS IN THE 21ST CENTURY, WARNS WILLIAM HAGUE AS RUSSIA DEFIANTLY THREATENS A MILITARY ASSAULT ON CRIMEA. THE INDEPENDENT. 5 MARCH. IN: HTTPS://WWW.INDEPENDENT.CO.UK/NEWS/WORLD/EUROPE/UKRAINE-CRISIS-WESTERN-COUNTRIES-SCRAMBLE-TO-RESPOND-TO-RUSSIA-AS-ACTING-PRESIDENT-APPEALS-TO-MOSCOW-9166748.HTML [ACCESS: 16 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

NATO’S ENHANCED FORWARD PRESENCE (2019). MARCH. IN: HTTPS://WWW.NATO.INT/NATO_STATIC_FL2014/ASSETS/PDF/PDF_2019_04/20190402_1904-FACTSHEET_EFP_EN.PDF [ACCESS: 16 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

NEUMANN, I. B. (2013), RUSSIA IN INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY OVER THE LONGUE DURÉE: LESSONS FROM EARLY RUS’ AND EARLY POST SOVIET STATE FORMATION. IN: TARAS, R. (ED.), RUSSIA’S IDENTITY IN INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS. IMAGES, PER-CEPTIONS, MISPERCEPTIONS. LONDON/NEW YORK, 24-41.   Google Scholar

NEUMANN, I. B. (2017), RUSSIA AND THE IDEA OF EUROPE. A STUDY IN IDENTITY AND INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS. SECOND EDITION. LONDON/NEW YORK.   Google Scholar

NORTHEDGE, F. S. (2013), BRITAIN'S PLACE IN THE CHANGING WORLD. IN: LEIFER, M. (ED.), CONSTRAINTS AND ADJUST-MENTS IN BRITISH FOREIGN POLICY. LONDON/NEW YORK, 192-208.   Google Scholar

PACKAGE OF MEASURES FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE MINSK AGREEMENTS (2015). MINSK. 11 FEBRUARY. IN: HTTPS://PEACEMAKER.UN.ORG/SITES/PEACEMAKER.UN.ORG/FILES/UA_150212_MINSKAGREEMENT_EN.PDF [ACCESS: 12 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

PERRAUDIN, F. (2015), UK GOVERNMENT DEFENDS ROLE IN UKRAINE-RUSSIA CRISIS. THE GUARDIAN. 10 FEBRUARY. IN: HTTPS://WWW.THEGUARDIAN.COM/POLITICS/2015/FEB/10/UK-GOVERNMENT-DEFENDS-ROLE-IN-UKRAINE-RUSSIA-CRISIS [ACCESS: 20 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

PIETNOCZKA, P. (2018), UKRAINE’S PATH TO EUROPEAN INTEGRATION. IN: PRZEGLĄD WSCHODNOEUROPEJSKI. IX/1, 153-165.
Crossref   Google Scholar

PONSARD, N. (2007), RUSSIA, NATO AND COOPERATIVE SECURITY. BRIDGING THE GAP. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

PROTOCOL ON THE RESULTS OF CONSULTATIONS OF THE TRILATERAL CONTACT GROUP (2014), MINSK. 5 SEPTEMBER. IN: HTTPS://WWW.OSCE.ORG/HOME/123257 [ACCESS: 12 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

ROWE, P. (2016), LEGAL ACCOUNTABILITY AND BRITAIN’S WARS 2000–2015. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

SHERR, J. (2008), RUSSIA AND GEORGIA: A DANGEROUS GAME. IN: THE WORLD TODAY. 64/10, 2-24.   Google Scholar

SIMPSON, J. (2015), THE US-UK SPECIAL RELATIONSHIP. THE NUCLEAR DIMENSION. IN: DOBSON, P./MARSH, S. (EDS.), ANGLO-AMERICAN RELATIONS. CONTEMPORARY PERSPECTIVES. LONDON/NEW YORK, 241-262.   Google Scholar

SMITH, M. A. (2016), THE UK AND NUCLEAR WEAPONS. IN: BROWN, D. (ED.), THE DEVELOPMENT OF BRITISH DEFENCE POLICY. BLAIR, BROWN AND BEYOND. LONDON/NEW YORK, 169-188.   Google Scholar

SNETKOV, A. (2015), RUSSIA’S SECURITY POLICY UNDER PUTIN. A CRITICAL PERSPECTIVE. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

STENT, A. (2010), GERMANY – RUSSIA RELATIONS. 1992-2009. IN: ENGELBREKT, K./NYGREN, B. (EDS), RUSSIA AND EU-ROPE. BUILDING BRIDGES, DIGGING TRENCHES. LONDON/NEW YORK, 156-166.
Crossref   Google Scholar

STRONG, J. (2017), PUBLIC OPINION, LEGITIMACY AND TONY BLAIR’S WAR IN IRAQ. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

TOMASZEWSKI, J. (2015), WYBRANE ASPEKTY POLITYKI BEZPIECZEŃSTWA WIELKIEJ BRYTANII. IN: BEZPIECZEŃSTWO NARODOWE. IV, 25-40.   Google Scholar

UK PERSPECTIVE ON UKRAINE CRISIS. IN: HTTP://WWW.GDFORUM.ORG/DD-UK-PERSPECTIVE-ON-UKRAINE-CRISIS [ACCESS: 16 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

U.S., UK STOP APPROVING EXPORT LICENSES FOR RUSSIA (2014), IN: WASHINGTON TARIFF & TRADE LETTER. 34/12, 1-2. IN: HTTP://WWW.WTTLONLINE.COM/HT/A/GETDOCUMENTACTION/I/54791 [ACCESS: 16 VIII 2019].   Google Scholar

WALL, S. (2013), THE OFFICIAL HISTORY OF BRITAIN AND THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITY. VOLUME II. LONDON/NEW YORK.
Crossref   Google Scholar

WHITE, B. (1992), BRITAIN, DÉTENTE AND CHANGING EAST-WEST RELATIONS. LONDON/NEW YORK.   Google Scholar

Download


Published
2021-09-24

Cited by

Jureńczyk, Łukasz. (2021). Controversies in Polish-Russian Relations over the Approach to Ukraine and Georgia. Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski, 12(1), 113–124. https://doi.org/10.31648/pw.6464

Łukasz Jureńczyk 
Uniwersytet Kazimierza Wielkiego w Bydgoszczy